What crap exactly do you put up with in regards to BYU?
Athletically, it's just that they won't play on Sundays. Otherwise, it's just being associated with a theocratic university. We already have Baylor and that is embarrassing enough.
That isn't true, their honor code,, still, in 2021 discriminates against the lgbtq community. However, I'm just going to sit that aside, we don't even need to discuss that.
The biggest pain in the ass is that they are in Provo, Utah. If you are adding teams and your budget is being cut, you can't have a conference with teams in Orlando, Morgantown, Houston, and Provo, that's insanity, football isn't the only sport that's played, the travel costs would be ridiculous.
Yes, BYU is very popular with Mormons, however the level of their popularity outside of the state of Utah is anecdotal. Their TV numbers aren't any better than the good schools in the AAC. Their enrollment and alumni base is in fact smaller than all those other schools except Memphis and Memphis' enrollment is similar to ours.
Did you know BYU also has their own network for their sports? It's called BYUtv and it's carriage is microscopic, you ever here of it?
If we expanded west and BYU modified their honor code I'd be happy to take them, like if we are going to go 16 instead of 12. But if we're going 12 it makes no sense to add them and no, they don't have more value than Cincinnati, Houston, or UCF. Memphis maybe, but not much. Memphis also gets the conference in a good recruiting area.