the biggest problem is that our fans are rational and don't expect him to do any better, but are also simultaneously ok w/ it. give him a chance guys! let's see what he can do guys! guys we don't even know who his assistants are! guys let's see how this all plays out first before we judge! umm, no. why? i've already seen it play out. no need to watch the same movie twice.
I certainly expect him to do better.
Based on what?
Based on the rest of his career. I already said I understand the caution, but I also don't think its impossible for him to learn from what happened last year and not repeat it.
I won't give him excuses, but his two terrible years had very different circumstances, so I don't see him repeating the same mistake twice as being the key to his failure at Illinois.
The first time was legitimately a rebuilding year with some injuries and recruiting failures mixed in. After that season he recovered.
Last year the recruiting was fine, even really good. It was not a rebuilding year, there was plenty of talent to win with, even with young players. But clearly he did a poor job implimenting everything he needed to sustain success with that group and he failed to turn them around after losing started. Eventually he lost his team, but it was a team with enough talent to win. Of the two failed season, this is the most concerning.
I know you can't eliminate those years from his resume, they are part of who Weber as a coach is. They concern me, but I can also look at the rest of his resume and see that is not impossible for him to learn enough from his time at Illinois to avoid repeating those mistakes.