Peanut Butter

[_33]

Members Mark™ Natural No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter is the best there is. And trust me, I've had all the name brands.

JiF®, Skippy®, Peter Pan®? Garbage compared to Members Mark™ Natural No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter.

Don't let this fool you into thinking all generics are great. Both Great Value™ and Good and Gather™ have peanut butter that is inedible trash.

Pick up a 2-pack of Members Mark™ Natural No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter at your local Sam's Club® and see what I mean! You'll never go back to the name brands.

[bucket]

Looks to be Sam's Club only? Am I reading that correctly? As a daily peanut butter consumer, I would like to know. Skippy guy, fwiw.

[yoga-like_abana]

Kroger Creamy Honey Roasted Peanut Butter

[_33]

Looks to be Sam's Club only? Am I reading that correctly? As a daily peanut butter consumer, I would like to know. Skippy guy, fwiw.

That's the only place I've bought it. Worth the membership IYAM.

[CHONGS]

JiF is the best.  Anyone else who says otherwise is a virtue signalling hipster.

[nicname]

I’ve never had discernibly bad peanut butter.

[Stupid Fitz]

if you don't have to stir it, it has gross added stuff in it.

[_33]

JiF is the best.  Anyone else who says otherwise is a virtue signalling hipster.

Listen, JiF is fine. It's the #2 named brand peanut butter and #3 overall. But don't kid yourself, it's absolutely not Members Mark™ Natural No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter and it never will be.

[Spracne]

if you don't have to stir it, it has gross added stuff in it.

And that gross stuff is convenience, enjoyment, fulfillment.

I'm a whatever Aldi's generic brand is guy.

[star seed 7]

Reese's.

[CHONGS]

JiF is the best.  Anyone else who says otherwise is a virtue signalling hipster.

Listen, JiF is fine. It's the #2 named brand peanut butter and #3 overall. But don't kid yourself, it's absolutely not Members Mark Natural No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter and it never will be.

I didn't even realize you said creamy.  That should also be condemned.  I guess that's what happens when everybody gets a trophy.

[Sandstone Outcropping]

JiF is the best.  Anyone else who says otherwise is a virtue signalling hipster.

JiF crunchy. End of discussion.

[_33]

LOL another JiF fanboy. I'm sure it reminds you of when your mom cut the crust off your Iron Kids PB&J but now it's time to grow up omg unbelievable.

[_33]

JiF is the best.  Anyone else who says otherwise is a virtue signalling hipster.

Listen, JiF is fine. It's the #2 named brand peanut butter and #3 overall. But don't kid yourself, it's absolutely not Members Mark Natural No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter and it never will be.

I didn't even realize you said creamy.  That should also be condemned.  I guess that's what happens when everybody gets a trophy.

Listen, I have enjoyed crunchy peanut butter in the past. It's fine. And if you've decided 'fine' is good enough for you then I won't try to change your mind. Just know... if you ever decide to break free from 'fine', Members Mark™ Natural No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter will be there.

[CHONGS]

I've heard people say that an adult eating creamy peanut butter is the number one indicator for SBS (stinky butt syndrome). 

[_33]

I've heard people say that an adult eating creamy peanut butter is the number one indicator for SBS (stinky butt syndrome).

Sounds made up. 

[mocat]

the only PB i've found that doesn't have added sugar is Smucker's natural PB. so that's what i always get (crunchy ofc). you have to stir it once when you first open it, so that might be a deal breaker for some.

[KITNfury]

Of you really want to treat yourself to a calorie bomb, mix peanut butter and clear corn syrup until the peanut butter starts to "glisten" a little. Put in on bread of choice.

[Phil Titola]

SKIPPY Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread is on auto reorder

[Brock Landers]

RE: crunchy vs creamy PB debate.  Crunchy is for when you eat it straight out of the jar, creamy is for PB&J sammiches.

[Phil Titola]

Crunchy is for psychos

[mocat]

if you are militantly against peanuts being in peanut butter, i am curious what it is that you like about peanut butter.

[Stupid Fitz]

the only PB i've found that doesn't have added sugar is Smucker's natural PB. so that's what i always get (crunchy ofc). you have to stir it once when you first open it, so that might be a deal breaker for some.

This is the #1 PB followed by Kirkland Organic as a close second.

[star seed 7]

if you are militantly against peanuts being in peanut butter, i am curious what it is that you like about peanut butter.

Butter isn't chunky

[mocat]

if you are militantly against peanuts being in peanut butter, i am curious what it is that you like about peanut butter.

Butter isn't chunky

Peanut butter is