Guys, I can't seem to get the app installed on the lost phone, or be able to control it. I'm not sure what the problem is. It's installed on my current phone (same kind) and works pretty well.
On the app site forum it says that when multiple devices are connected to the app a drop down menu will appear and allow you to choose which device to interact with, but I'm not finding any drop down menu.
I'll see if anything changes. If it fails it looks like we're left with just the location notifications that I've been using the whole time.
Sorry to disappoint.