Paulino: If he keeps up like he pitched this season, legitimate #2 to #1, but probably more a #3 or #4. Coming off TJ surgery.
Guthrie: #2 is his ceiling, but given his history and age, probably #3 or #4 next year.
Duffy: Probably #2 at best. Coming off TJ surgery.
Mendoza: #3 maybe. His rate and park adjusted stats aren't that good.
Hochever is what he is, a back end guy.
Chen is 35 years old
We have Oderizzi and who else waiting in the wings? I think we really need to sign 2 starters, one a top of the rotation guy, one in the middle, if we want to have any hope of approaching contention by the time Duffy and Paulino get back, and who knows if / how long until they will be effective again.