I may not be an expert, but ill certainly be more objective than most here, I imagine.
Waters really looked like a guy who was playing in his first big boy game. He was entirely too slow making check-downs, but he had almost zero help from that O-line. The more important problem I saw was decision making, or more specifically, the lack of it. The combination of having no help to find time to make the right decisions and the fact that he apparently needs MORE than a whole offseason to get ONE play called did not a good plan make.
Truly sorry about this loss, guys. T's and P's…