Once non-NFSW material is open to moderation, how do you decide where to draw the line? and who decides?
This is just my opinion, but what makes goEMAW work is that in effect this place is community-owned. Not being a "rebel" board or whatever that means. You want to make a banner for the site, go ahead and do it, we'll probably add it. Make a cool video, we'll promote it. Have great blog ideas or an article you want published, we'll provide you a platform to do so.
There is nothing wrong with goEMAW that cannot be cured by what is right with goEMAW. It's just sometimes the good is not very active about it.