is the jeep just a nostalgic thing and 4wd or are you planning on modding it for some off road use?
I don't know about newest jeeps post buy out but older jeeps had a rep for rust.
I would stay away from VW/Audi just for the random electrical issues that seem to always pop up with them.
BMW is souless mommy transporters, same with MB ML class
New Dodge Durangos have caught on fire, so built in heater for winter is a plus
I would think about a new Explorer. The new body style is hot. Maybe a Flex or edge. unfortunately you can't get the ecoboost in 4wd, only fwd on the edge. but for a good bit of coin you can get a flex with ecoboost engine and awd. But at the price required I would rather have an explorer I think.
Subarus are nice cars but they are losing their souls. Outbacks should not be small SUVs I would still kill and early 2000s with a quickness in LLB edition. Foresters are huge pigs now. I've thought about a WRX hatch for a next car. manual/turbo/hatch for space would be great. AWD for them is proven, especially if you aren't modding.