Pondering*
Dumb?

*Before iPhone, I had several HTC products and like them all. Not really into Samsung/Motorola/etc.
poor battery choice
I went ahead and got it, but waited a week to see how it was knowing that I could return it under Verizon's 14 day policy. The biggest critiques in reviews were battery and no expandable memory, but neither have been issues for me. Battery life is slightly better than what I got with my iPhone 4s, and 16G of storage (12G really) is plenty for me.
On the positive side the screen and speed/smoothness of the phone is really good. I'm glad I didn't wait for iPhone 5, and I don't really miss iOS at all. Android and iOS are both good systems, but I am enjoying some of the customization features in Android and the system is better than it was more than a year ago when I switched to iPhone. The 5" screen is big, but its not a negative for me. 1080p HD screen with 440 pixels per inch is really cool, but I will admit it is over the top ridiculous on a phone since your eye really can't recognize the difference.
Plus, I get 4G all over Manhattan and it is fast. It was nice to be at the game Saturday and have no problems checking stats, twitter etc. with the 4G signal and not depleting the battery trying to find 3G signal like my 4s did at games.