If we extend it to the last three years, Uribe has worse numbers than the two candidates for him to really take much playing time from. Also, the idea that Uribe is all of a sudden going to go back to playing the middle infield at age 34 after spending the last two years almost exclusively at the corners is absurd. If he is going to play it is going to be at the expense of Moustakas who has had a similar, if not slightly better line in recent history, and inarguably has more upside than Uribe at this point.
I guess it comes down to whether you think he is an old player that suddenly found it again and will be able to sustain it, or if last year was a flash in the pan.
PA BA / OBP/ SLG / OPS
Uribe (age 34) 900 .237/.294/.360/.654
Bonifacio (28) 1376 .270/.332/.356/.688
Moustakas (24) 1493 .244/.296/.385/.681
Getz (29) 876 .251/.306/.301/.607
Tejada (39) 510 .255/.285/.343/.628
Escobar (26) 1888 .260/.294/.344/.638
Hosmer (24) 1841 .277/.322/.425/.756
Gordon (29) 2111 .287/.357/.459/.816
Butler (27) 2020 .297/.369/.462/.830