Did Pete even live through the lin elliot debacle? Having a great kicker who is absolute nails in the postseason is worth its weight in gold (or .25 million more than the next highest paid kicker).
I highly doubt we win our last 2 super bowls if we replaced butker with a league average kicker.
So this phrase "worth its weight in gold" ...
Butker is getting paid ~$6.5 million per year (average over the next 4 years) and weighs about 200 pounds, so he makes about $2,000 per ounce
Gold is something like ~$2,400 /ounce right now [daymn]
So he is getting paid close to, but somewhat less than, his weight in gold this year. Seems like a hell of a bargain to me.