Thought provoking question: Most overrated cat fballer??

['taterblast]

i think i have a really good one... Scott Edmonds

[yoga-like_abana]

Marcus Watts

hated

Was this a widely held belief or just yours?  I remember him as being a fan favorite.

hated as well

[michigancat]

Marcus Watts

hated

Was this a widely held belief or just yours?  I remember him as being a fan favorite.

Fair question. Didn't he like peak as a sophomore and be pretty frustrating after that?

[michigancat]

Jesse Tetuan

everybody hated him

People are just trolling me now

['taterblast]

Watts is probably a good one, i think people loved him

[Paul Moscow]

Marcus Watts

hated

Was this a widely held belief or just yours?  I remember him as being a fan favorite.

overrated only in the sense that he set expectations really high in 2005 then his hip exploded and he was put into an ambulance in the last game against Mizzou and he was never the same again

[Rage Against the McKee]

Jesse Tetuan

everybody hated him

Doesn't mean he wasn't still overrated.

[8manpick]

Ian Campbell?

[steve dave]

Watts is probably a good one, i think people loved him

Yes, I think Watts is a good one.

['taterblast]

Ian Campbell?

20.5 career sacks and a pick 6 is pretty good

[steve dave]

The QB transfer from South Florida that like couldn’t use his broken arm because it was mumped up but he toughed it out and our fans loved his toughness and persevered and sucked bigtime (a ksu tradition like no other)

[steve dave]

And then his brother came to ksufans or here or wherever and defended his honor

[michigancat]

The QB transfer from South Florida that like couldn’t use his broken arm because it was mumped up but he toughed it out and our fans loved his toughness and persevered and sucked bigtime (a ksu tradition like no other)

Oh hell yeah. Grant Gregory. His brother came after me!

[8manpick]

Ian Campbell?

20.5 career sacks and a pick 6 is pretty good

Okay. Top of my head. I remembered one really great game, and maybe it was a good sophomore season that he didn’t live up to after?

['taterblast]

that is true he was a monster soph year then sputtered out a bit in terms of stats (sacks)

[Brock Landers]

Was Marcus Watts singled out by Ronny as the original FP?  Not sure why but that's how I remember it.  I'm probably wrong.

[catastrophe]

Jesse Ertz

[chum1]

Klein. Tremendous player. Heisman finalist, though?

[420seriouscat69]

The QB transfer from South Florida that like couldn’t use his broken arm because it was mumped up but he toughed it out and our fans loved his toughness and persevered and sucked bigtime (a ksu tradition like no other)

Oh hell yeah. Grant Gregory. His brother came after me!

Don't you either have to have high expectations as a recruit or have a good season in CFB, only to fall of into oblivion to be considered overrated? We knew we were getting a broken down transfer when he got here. I think some fans liked him because he played the most skettibrained vs any other QB in K-State history, other than Evridge.

https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/grant-gregory-1.html

[Paul Moscow]

overrated where definition is incoming hype > on-field performance

josh freeman
lamark brown
clinkscales
smoke patterson
marvin simmons
rashaad norwood
daniel davis
bryce brown
demarcus robinson
gary chandler

[bucket]

The QB transfer from South Florida that like couldn’t use his broken arm because it was mumped up but he toughed it out and our fans loved his toughness and persevered and sucked bigtime (a ksu tradition like no other)

Oh hell yeah. Grant Gregory. His brother came after me!

Don't you either have to have high expectations as a recruit or have a good season in CFB, only to fall of into oblivion to be considered overrated? We knew we were getting a broken down transfer when he got here. I think some fans liked him because he played the most skettibrained vs any other QB in K-State history, other than Evridge.

https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/grant-gregory-1.html

He was fun because the team sucked but finished one game out from winning the north. He laid it all out there.

[bucket]

Ian Campbell?

20.5 career sacks and a pick 6 is pretty good

Okay. Top of my head. I remembered one really great game, and maybe it was a good sophomore season that he didn’t live up to after?

Ian Campbell was a jerk! 

[yoga-like_abana]

Gonna be unpopular.. Chris Harper

[steve dave]

The QB transfer from South Florida that like couldn’t use his broken arm because it was mumped up but he toughed it out and our fans loved his toughness and persevered and sucked bigtime (a ksu tradition like no other)

Oh hell yeah. Grant Gregory. His brother came after me!

Don't you either have to have high expectations as a recruit or have a good season in CFB, only to fall of into oblivion to be considered overrated? We knew we were getting a broken down transfer when he got here. I think some fans liked him because he played the most skettibrained vs any other QB in K-State history, other than Evridge.

https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/grant-gregory-1.html

He was fun because the team sucked but finished one game out from winning the north. He laid it all out there.

HE LAID IT ALL OUT THERE!

See! This is what I’m talking about. Classic ksu fan over rating.

[steve dave]

Gonna be unpopular.. Chris Harper

I think by nature every one that is mentioned has to be unpopular (or isn’t a good example)