The more I think about it, the more unlikely it seems that ACC schools will join the Big 12.
The Tobacco Road mafia (UNC, Duke, Wake, NCSt) are completely committed to the ACC and have no interest in leaving. UVA is a charter member of the ACC with strong ties to the Carolina four and have no interest in leaving. UVA and the state of Virginia used strong-arm tactics to force Va Tech's inclusion in the ACC several years ago. Va Tech will simply not be allowed to leave as a result. Boston College and Syracuse are not at all attractive to the Big 12 and would not be considered even if they wanted to come. Georgia Tech appears completely happy in the ACC, rubbing elbows with the academic elite in North Carolina and Virginia. Miami's football program is squarely in the NCAA's bullseye and deserves the death penalty (though it will probably be a little less than that, they are going to be punished severly).
Who does that leave? Maryland, Clemson, Florida State and Pitt.
- Pitt had the chance to join the Big 12 last year when they were in discussions with us, but chose the ACC instead.
- Despite Maryland's budget issues, I have a hard time imaging them leaving. Like UVA, they are a charter member of the ACC. Their rivalries are in the ACC. Their identity is based on the east coast. If they were to entertain the idea of leaving the ACC, I think the only conf they'd go to would be the big 10, and that is only because the big 10 is academically elite like the ACC.
- Supposedly Clemson will not make the first move, but would be interested if Florida State made the move (see Chip Brown's info).
That brings us to Florida State. The Big 12's chances of luring in the Noles rests on what the Noles believe.
- Do they believe that ND is considering ACC membership? I think the answer is yes, they do believe this. I don't necessarily think they believe it's a strong chance, but I think they believe the ACC's chances are far better than the Big 12's chances of bringing in the Irish.
- Do they believe that they can continue to compete financially with Florida, even if the ACC's contract is only $18 mil/yr while the SEC's is $25 mil/yr? Keep in mind that FSU already has a deficit compared to UF based on the current ACC contract ($12.9 mil/yr) compared to the current SEC contract ($17 mil/yr) so there's not going to be a whole lot of change in that area.
- Do they believe that several eastern teams will join the Big 12 along with them if they decide to go? At best, I think Clemson would be likely but not guaranteed, and Maryland would likely say no but might be willing to listen. Would anyone else they care about say Yes or even get an invite?
- And if it looks like the Big 12 is only expanding to 12, would FSU think it is worth their while to join a league based halfway across the country composed almost entirely of schools with whom FSU has nothing in common? The revenue differences would have to be astronomical, and I just don't think ESPN values the Big 12 THAT much more than they value the ACC.
I think FSU's best case scenario would be to stay in the ACC. The ACC would sign a competitive TV contract, the ACC schools would improve their football programs and FSU could be one of the major players in an eastern league that is considered one of the Big Boys in college football. Failing that, I think FSU's fall back position would be to join the SEC. The SEC is already the premiere conference in the country and is paid accordingly. And that would put FSU in a southeastern league with a bunch of regional schools to continue or resume rivalries with. Only if both of those options fall through, would FSU consider the Big 12. And even then, I think they might choose to stay in the ACC anyway.
My opinion, if it starts to look like FSU is seriously considering the Big 12, the SEC would swoop in with an offer and the Noles would take it. The SEC would still have one opening, so they could still try to pry loose a school in VA or NC if they wanted, or they could consider Miami, or they could even change their minds on WVU or maybe try again for one of the Oklahoma schools or look at SMU in Dallas. Most likely, the SEC and ACC will each stay at 14 teams. The Big 12 will stay at 10 or add Louisville and ??? (USF? BYU? Rutgers? UConn?) to expand to 12, and then the realignment craze will die down for a few years.