This is what sucks about Weber. You have to form relationships based on mutual respect for this type of "punishment" to work. I used to teach 5th grade, and another teacher on my team was a complete bitch. She had no interest in her students, made no effort to interact with them, and then was shocked when they would just roll their eyes or ignore her when she would punish them. On the other hand, I invested a lot of time bonding with the students. They respected me, because they knew that I respected them. Sure, they got pissed off at me, but they also responded in a way that the bitchy teacher could never get out of them.