Who was better?

[SuperG]

My gut reaction is Michael. But I don't know why. I've never looked at the stats or anything. I kind of assumed that it was a given, but then I just thought about it and it's not a given really.

Please help me. Vote.

[bfred]

michael for sure, regardless of... I can't even type it out, too painful 

[SuperG]

It is the thing that we shall not speak of. Thank you for not.

[Cautiously Optimistic]

Oh... are you guys talking about the time Bishop fumbled the ball in the Big XII Championship?  And if I remember right he could have just taken a knee and the game would have been over and we would have played for the National Championship and most likely won it!!!!!  Is that what you're talking about?

[GP76]

Michael take a knee!!!  Are you drunk already....   To even say Michael and take a knee in the same sentence show me how mistaken you are about who he was.   That is exactly why he was the best.

[KSUTOMMY]

Michael take a knee!!!  Are you drunk already....   To even say Michael and take a knee in the same sentence show me how mistaken you are about who he was.   That is exactly why he was the best.

d00d was a gamer to a fault, thats for sure. but I vote for Michael, he had a CANNON on his shoulder and he made sugar out of $h!t on more occasions than I can remember.

[jthutch]

Bishop made Donavin McNabb look like at 2nd rate QB in the Feista Bowl, Our Defense helped a little too.

[Pete]

Bishop by a country mile.

Both of them did stupid stuff that cost us big games, but Bishop was at least trying to score on the football field when his mistake occurred.  Plus, Bishop was WAY better at playing football than Ell.

[PurplePride74]

Bishop made Donavin McNabb look like at 2nd rate QB in the Feista Bowl, Our Defense helped a little too.

Always wondered after watching that game...  Why did McNabb make it in NFL and Bishop not even get a sniff?  Weren't they both "dual threat" type QB's?

Educate me please, TIA.

[Pete]

Bishop made Donavin McNabb look like at 2nd rate QB in the Feista Bowl, Our Defense helped a little too.

Always wondered after watching that game...  Why did McNabb make it in NFL and Bishop not even get a sniff?  Weren't they both "dual threat" type QB's?

Educate me please, TIA.

Mike has some troubles with the NFL playbook.  Words in it and so forth....

[jaa1025]

Bishop made Donavin McNabb look like at 2nd rate QB in the Feista Bowl, Our Defense helped a little too.

Always wondered after watching that game...  Why did McNabb make it in NFL and Bishop not even get a sniff?  Weren't they both "dual threat" type QB's?

Educate me please, TIA.

Michael had the physical tools but lacked everything above his shoulders...he really struggled with the playbook that NE had apparently. Which BTW, if he would have played 5 years later he would have been a #1 pick IMO. He's lightyears better than Tebow. I think he was better than Michael Vick as well...just not AS fast.

[pwrcat1]

Bish, for all the above stated reasons.  Plus, being 1st cousins with Jaime Foxx just drips w/ eliteness.  This elite train goes both ways, too, 'cause take away Foxx's familial relations to the Bish and his movies become uglier than a baboons butt.

[cas]

Bish is better.

But I love Ell more.

[sonofchadmay]

Ell.  He won a conference championship.  Completely clown suited OU.  Warrior.  Getting in Lord's face prior to the game and then backing it up was certainly elite.  If he would have kept it in his pants that night (or at least in his girlfriends instead of the crazy chick) he would have a Fiesta Bowl too. 

[Olathecatbanker]

Snyder QB's
Best was Bishop but it is close
Toughest was Carl Straw, dude had nothing in front of him when Snyder got here.
Favorite was Beasley, fat and slow but 2-0 in big bowl games, bailed out Bishop against TT, the 00 game against nu with the snow at the end 
Worst was Smargessio dude was such a prick that the o-line ole blocked.

[hemmy]

Oh... are you guys talking about the time Bishop fumbled the ball in the Big XII Championship?  And if I remember right he could have just taken a knee and the game would have been over and we would have played for the National Championship and most likely won it!!!!!  Is that what you're talking about?

You do not remember right.