1. Ted Kennedy (duh)
2. Charles Manson
3. Axl Rose
4. Barak Hussein Obama
5. Keanu Reeves (we can hope)
2. Eligible for parole in 2012, will be 78 yrs old

5. Very unlikely he will "return to the source" in 2009, unless he develops a sushi fetish and gets mercury poisoning like Jeremy Piven.
That being said, the good ones always die young and the bad ones seem to live long enough for everyone to forget about them. So, here's my 5 nominees for "Italian-American Actor from New York Most Likely to go to the big studio in the sky" (in no particular order):
1. Sylvester Gardenzio Stallone
2. Robert Mario De Niro, Jr.
3. Alfredo James Pacino
4. Antonio Salvatore ladanza (Tony Danza)
5. Vincent Phillip D'Onofrio