I don't think the heisman is or should be the deciding factor as to whether or not a guy is a great college player. Mack's had/has talent, that's for sure, but he wins, just cause he doesn't go undefeated every year doesn't make him a bad coach. Even if people want to call him a horrible "in game coach", he makes up for it by doing the other part of "coaching" which is recruiting (or rather hiring the appropriate personnel to do the recruiting). People act like Bill never squandered any talent or something.