Well, looking at this debate the most non-powertardy way possible, which I believe is objectively as possible, it all probably really depends on what your preference is. Do you like the more traditional stuff or the more new shiny stuff? KU fans are obviously going to embrace tradition being that they have a lot. and naturally Allen is just going to give them the biggest throbbing flesh pole ever, and they have no idea how anyone could prefer anything else. Personally I'm probably in the middle but I know a lot of people that would much rather be in a brand new facility. And those that respect ku's tradition but just don't care about it much, like me, just won't appreciate Allen the same way.
So basically, enjoy your crumbling smelly building, I totally get it, but don't go crazy when others don't get what the big deal is.