All kidding aside, why the foooock not pull Cosh's redshirt?
There are only two possible reasons.
1) he's no better than the others
2) even if he's better, it won't be enough to overcome our other deficiencies.
Also, both could be true.
Look, I heard some "talk" out of practice that Cosh was doing well. Do you know what I also used to hear? That Coffman was tearing it up on the scout team. Hell, Lynn Dickey came to a KC Catbackers two years ago and speculated that Josh should be benched because the better quarterback at practice was Coffman....NOT JOKING.
However, the most important difference for mean between Carson and Billy is that Skip Holtz and Rich Brooks both offered Billy, and UNT was the only D1 school to offer Carson a scholarship.