Propane v Charcoal. Grilling Thread

[KSUBrian]

In a straight up gas vs. charcoal challenge I bet most posters wouldn't be able to tell a taste difference.

Only if you use briquettes and not natural lump charcoal.  Only a tard would use briquettes and lighter fluid.

[CNS]

I've got both, propane during the week.  charcoal on the weekends.

This is what I have been thinking.

[pissclams]

In a straight up gas vs. charcoal challenge I bet most posters wouldn't be able to tell a taste difference.

Only if you use briquettes and not natural lump charcoal.  Only a tard would use briquettes and lighter fluid.

since 95% of the population uses briquettes and lighter fluid, my statement stands.

[CHONGS]

In a straight up gas vs. charcoal challenge I bet most posters wouldn't be able to tell a taste difference.

Only if you use briquettes and not natural lump charcoal.  Only a tard would use briquettes and lighter fluid.

since 95% of the population uses briquettes and lighter fluid, my statement stands.

I use a stove.

[pissclams]

In a straight up gas vs. charcoal challenge I bet most posters wouldn't be able to tell a taste difference.

Only if you use briquettes and not natural lump charcoal.  Only a tard would use briquettes and lighter fluid.

since 95% of the population uses briquettes and lighter fluid, my statement stands.

I use a stove.

wrong thread dumbace

[CHONGS]

In a straight up gas vs. charcoal challenge I bet most posters wouldn't be able to tell a taste difference.

Only if you use briquettes and not natural lump charcoal.  Only a tard would use briquettes and lighter fluid.

since 95% of the population uses briquettes and lighter fluid, my statement stands.

I use a stove.

wrong thread dumbace

I'm sorry junior mod. (not really, I am being sarcastic because I think you're all dumbasses for not using a stove)

[Dr Rick Daris]

In a straight up gas vs. charcoal challenge I bet most posters wouldn't be able to tell a taste difference.

Only if you use briquettes and not natural lump charcoal.  Only a tard would use briquettes and lighter fluid.

since 95% of the population uses briquettes and lighter fluid, my statement stands.

I use a stove.

wrong thread dumbace

I'm sorry junior mod. (not really, I am being sarcastic because I think you're all dumbasses for not using a stove)

Tell me more about "the stove". Is it like the bge?

[Pete]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

[Saulbadguy]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

Doubt you can. Just an "fyi".

[OK_Cat]

Propane FTW.

Who the eff are you? Hank Hill? Charcoal is so much better that it compensates for it being a pain in the ass to get warm (most of the time.) 

Damnit, Bobby.

Damnit, Bobby.

[Rage Against the McKee]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

Doubt you can. Just an "fyi".

There is a huge difference in taste between charcoal and gas grills. The only reason that somebody might fail a blind test is if they actually prefer the food off the gas grill and just expect the charcoal to taste better, or vice versa.

[WillieWatanabe]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

Doubt you can. Just an "fyi".

There is a huge difference in taste between charcoal and gas grills. The only reason that somebody might fail a blind test is if they actually prefer the food off the gas grill and just expect the charcoal to taste better, or vice versa.

that makes no sense at all.

[Rage Against the McKee]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

Doubt you can. Just an "fyi".

There is a huge difference in taste between charcoal and gas grills. The only reason that somebody might fail a blind test is if they actually prefer the food off the gas grill and just expect the charcoal to taste better, or vice versa.

that makes no sense at all.

Charcoal grills give a distinct flavor to food. The only reason somebody would prefer a gas grill is if they don't like that flavor. What doesn't make sense about that?

[pissclams]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

Doubt you can. Just an "fyi".

There is a huge difference in taste between charcoal and gas grills. The only reason that somebody might fail a blind test is if they actually prefer the food off the gas grill and just expect the charcoal to taste better, or vice versa.

that makes no sense at all.

Charcoal grills give a distinct flavor to food. The only reason somebody would prefer a gas grill is if they don't like that flavor. What doesn't make sense about that?

hey pancho, neither is worth bragging about.

[WillieWatanabe]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

Doubt you can. Just an "fyi".

There is a huge difference in taste between charcoal and gas grills. The only reason that somebody might fail a blind test is if they actually prefer the food off the gas grill and just expect the charcoal to taste better, or vice versa.

that makes no sense at all.

Charcoal grills give a distinct flavor to food. The only reason somebody would prefer a gas grill is if they don't like that flavor. What doesn't make sense about that?

hey pancho, neither is worth bragging about.

well, the only way it wouldn't make sense is if I knew what you were saying, or liked what your were saying, or liked what you weren't saying, or vice versa.

[PandaXpanda]

grilling is an adventure.  go w/ the charcoal. 

[Rage Against the McKee]

hey pancho, neither is worth bragging about.

No kidding. That's why I cook with a wood fire stove.

[jmlynch1]

I like Burger King so I guess I'm going to have to go with Charcoal.

[michigancat]

You know what's the ultimate?  A medium-well steak cooked on a propane grill and slathered in A1. 

[Brock Landers]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

Doubt you can. Just an "fyi".

There is a huge difference in taste between charcoal and gas grills. The only reason that somebody might fail a blind test is if they actually prefer the food off the gas grill and just expect the charcoal to taste better, or vice versa.

that makes no sense at all.

Charcoal grills give a distinct flavor to food. The only reason somebody would prefer a gas grill is if they don't like that flavor. What doesn't make sense about that?

hey pancho, neither is worth bragging about.

well, the only way it wouldn't make sense is if I knew what you were saying, or liked what your were saying, or liked what you weren't saying, or vice versa.

Only a dumbass who just underwent tastebud removal surgery wouldn't be able to notice the difference in taste between charcoal vs. propane cooked food.  Just sayin'

[WillieWatanabe]

well, the only way it wouldn't make sense is if I knew what you were saying, or liked what your were saying, or liked what you weren't saying, or vice versa.

Only a dumbass who just underwent tastebud removal surgery wouldn't be able to notice the difference in taste between charcoal vs. propane cooked food.  Just sayin'

NOT THE POINT, BROCK LANDERS!!!

[CNS]

You know what's the ultimate?  A medium-well steak cooked on a propane grill and slathered in A1. 

A1 is for people who are eating poorly cooked steak.

[CNS]

I can definitely tell a difference between charcoal and gas grilled food.  I prefer charcoal, but gas is much simpler, obviously.

Doubt you can. Just an "fyi".

There is a huge difference in taste between charcoal and gas grills. The only reason that somebody might fail a blind test is if they actually prefer the food off the gas grill and just expect the charcoal to taste better, or vice versa.

that makes no sense at all.

Gonna get the Gas, cook food for people, but lie and tell them it was charcoal. 

Seems like the best of both worlds.   

[pissclams]

You know what's the ultimate?  A medium-well steak cooked on a propane grill and slathered in A1. 

try this- marinate your steak overnight in A1 before cooking it, heaven.  also, try the bold and spicy A1, me thinks it has tabasco in it 

[michigancat]

You know what's the ultimate?  A medium-well steak cooked on a propane grill and slathered in A1. 

try this- marinate your steak overnight in A1 before cooking it, heaven.  also, try the bold and spicy A1, me thinks it has tabasco in it 

combine it with ribs that fall of the bone, and you're in heaven.