Whole lotta rib noobs 'round here. You do know that the majority of restaurants braise their ribs before grilling them, right? And you know that a broiler is basically just an upside down grill, right? If this thread was entitled: "Smoking Ribs," you guys might have a point. The problem is- you have to smoke for so many hours to really impart any real sense of smoke flavoring and sometimes people want to eat in an hour or two, rather than 8 hours later. Also, Alton Brown is an incredibly knowledgeable guy about pretty much everything food related.