The Rheem's and Gramatica provided us with like 10 years of excellent to above average kicking. It's those guys that make average to below average kickers seem terrible, i.e. Cherry.
College kickers overall pretty much suck. I'm always reminded of this when I watch a bowl game, and Nevada or Oregon State or someone like trots out some guy that looks like he's never shaved. ESPN will throw his season stats up on the screen and it looks something like this: 4FG's 11FGA's Long 34 yards.
I do think they're probably all douche-bags though. I remember Snodgrass was kind of a tool. I think it's probably because they're all really soccer players dressed up in a football costume.