I would take a natty IMHO
Be careful what you wish for. I have a friend who is a Bama fan and honestly it looks miserable, there are maybe 3 regular season games a year that matter and anything less than a national title is a disappointment.
I mean yeah it would be great to win a natty but I DO NOT WANT to run off 6 in 9 years which is where I think CK has us heading.