I think some of you may be going to Vegas for the wrong reasons
indeed.
I've stayed at luxor, monte carlo RIP, Park MGM, Vdara, Flamingo, Rio (woof), Horseshoe/Bally's and Paris. I liked all of them for various reasons. The only one I wouldn't stay at again is Luxor. It's just too far away from the poker rooms and casinos I like the most. I'd like to do a midweek trip some time, so I can afford a real high end place like Aria, Venetian or Wynn some time. Though tbh, I feel like a fish out of water at the Wynn (outside of the poker room).
Some of the places downtown are really terrible quality like Casino Royale or Harrah's are on The Strip, but Circa and the Golden Nugget are nice properties. I've heard The D is a blast as well. I just never stay downtown cuz the nugget is the only place w poker. I do enjoy my time there tho. It's fun.
This last trip was the first one where I really "Vegas'd" in any real way, and I enjoyed it a lot and wasn't pining for home even after 5 days.
Three off-strip recommendos:
Bootleggers Italian, longtime local joint that used to be in the old El Rancho, but is not south of the airport on LV BLVD. Great food and drinks and normal prices. live music often in the evening for dinner.
McMullen's Irish Pub: another local place that has been around awhile. really good irish pub food and great beer and drinks. cool crowd and staff.
Texas de Brazil: like Fogo De Ciao or however it is spelled. forget exactly where it is.
I've heard Herbs n Rye is good.