I decided to put together a chart that takes the major advanced stats and attempts to correlate which factors have the most impact on winning and losing for oscar teams. For "success" my mark was finishing in the kenpom Top 50 and making the NCAA tournament. For this chart I only looked at oscar's Illinois and K-State teams.
First a brief explanation of the chart:
The first 5 columns focus on the offensive numbers. Column 1 is the factor, column two is the rough goal I set by sorting each factor, roughly staying at the median for each stat. The 3rd and 4th column show what percentage of oscar teams were NCAA/kenpom top 50 when matching or surpassing the goal (>) and what percentage were "successful" when finishing below (<) the goal. The 5th column is this year's current numbers; green is good, red is bad, gray is neutral.
The next 5 columns do the same for defense. The last 5 columns are for offense - defense differential.
This isn't some absolute, but it does show which factors are most important for oscar teams to be successful, some we've talked about here before like 3PT%. Granted, these numbers would probably be similar for almost any coach, but the goal numbers probably would change up or down for each coach. For example, I'm certain OR% was a much more important factor for Frank as compared to oscar.