I think expansion to 12 with a North of KSU, KSU, ISU, WVU, BYU, and Cincy was in K-State's best interest. Sad to see that it didn't happen.
Now, I think it is in K-State's interest for the playoff to expand to 8.
Yeah if you like seasons where you never play a meaningful game. It's in our best interest then to quit the B12 and just move to the Sunbelt it you just want to play games against nobodies.
Games would be plenty meaningful. We wouldn't play OU or UT every year, but consistently being in the Big 12 championship game would more than make up for that.
No they wouldn't, well not to anyone outside of the very small bubble of KSU fans with inferiority complexes. I mean I am sure New Mexico thinks its game against New Mexico State is meaningful and FAU thinks its game against FIU is as well, but come on. You just want to pad the schedule with hollow victories against unranked teams it would almost certainly be in our best interest to drop down to a smaller conference. Then when KSU is 11-1 (with 1 victory over a ranked team) you can sit there and moan about the unfair media overlooking poor ole KSU and feel good about yourself.
Anything that improves Kstate's chances of winning a power conference is a good thing. Being in a north division, while getting paid same/more than our current contract, would have been superb for us. Comparisons to New Mexico or FIU miss the point, because they are not in a power conference. We are talking about adding two decent schools to our current set up. Yes, we would've played Ut and OU once a year rather than twice a year, but I don't really buy that simply playing them is a huge boon. Being in the same conference is a big deal, because we get paid for that. But after you have secured that, the next real jump is in winning the conference and making the playoffs. Adding Cincy and BYU would have greatly increased our chances of that happening.
And, no, I'm not saying we would win that north every year. But I think we win the conference more under that set up than we do in a ten team round robin with a championship game (even though, paradoxically, we go from being 1/10 to 1/12).
Plus--and this is not to be discounted--divisions are just fun. We would still have a chance to win our division at 1-2 this year. As it stands now, we have no shot to win the ten-team conference.