This is before pretty much everyone here's time but Anthony Davis for USC vs Notre Dame in 1974. Notre Dame was leading 24-0 when Davis scored on a swing pass into the flat just before halftime. He then returned the 2nd half kickoff 102 yards for a touchdown. He followed that up with two more rushing touchdowns in the first seven minutes of the third quarter to give USC a 28-24 lead. USC ended up putting on 55 unanswered points to win 55-24. Davis ends up finishing 2nd in the Heisman as Heisman votes were due in the week before the USC-Notre Dame game was played.
