Couple things..
First of all the guy is not Turner rough ridin' Gill..
He won 68% of his games in one of the best basketball conferences in the country and was there for nearly 10yrs..
First off lets talk about Illinois, they have sky high expectations and their program has NEVER done crap, Weber had probably the best career of any coach there ever.. They have 2 Final 4's in the modern era (one of which was under Weber), 3 Elite eights and very few conference titles.. Winning 20 games a year there is an accomplishment historically, and that's not even taking into account his impressive run at So. Illinois..
The notion that he can't recruit is B.S. too, it stems him from not being able to lock down elite Chicago talent, well guess what, Illinois has NEVER locked down elite chicago talent!! EVER!! Bill Self was able to land some of the 2nd tier guys but there were plenty of rumors that it wasn't all above board.. Chicago is a pro sports town, nobody gives a crap about the Illini, kids there don't grow up dreaming to play for them and even if they did it's pretty common knowledge that the elite chicago AAU kids come with a price tag.. Those kids go to blue blood programs or whoever pays the most, always have and always will.. He signed over 9 top 100 guys while at Illinois and had a couple more coming in.. Illinois always had talent under Weber though, even this year, his worst year ever he had one of the more talented rosters in the big 10.
Which leads to my next point, the knock on oscar is that he's a softy.. Pretty much the opposite of Frank Martin, he's very much a players coach which can be good but he's too much of a push over.. They are usually a talented but undisciplined team, especially lately as they haven't had a leader on the floor to keep the guys in line.. This year for example they were 15-3 atop the big 10 with wins over MSU,OSU,Gonzaga.. Had a lottery pick in Meyer Leonard and 2 great scorers in Paul,Richardson.. They finished with 17 wins, and were blown out by Nebraska.. If they have a good leader on the team ala Dee Brown they usually had good-great seasons, if they didn't have a true leader on the floor they would fold under the first sign of adversity and Brucie couldn't reel em back in..
I can understand not being excited about the hire, the guy has his warts, but he's not Wooldridge or Turner Gill. The guy went to an NC game for christsakes!! He's had some of the best career marks at both of his previous programs, the guy can coach and I think KSU is probably a better fit for a guy coach like oscar than Illinois..
I understand the frustration with your AD, he ran off a great coach on the rise in Martin and then went the 'safe' route when hiring his replacement, he seems like a rough ridin' moron.. Still, I don't think your basketball program is doomed, if Weber learned anything at all from his mistakes at Illinois he has the potential to do great things..
Just my opinion, feel free to shout me down and call me a dumbass..