turned out champ.

Made this last night. Never had John's Spicy before to compare to, but this was very good. Could hold a lot of heat due to cream, so if you like spicy food, make this and pack the heat in.
Also, I sauteed my two pepp's directly in my roux as soon as the roux reached the shade of light brown I wanted. keeps all the flavor in, saves a pan, and not only doesn't negatively affect how the cream mixes with the roux, but helps to cool the pan slightly since a pan gets so outrageously hot when making a roux. That way the cream didn't flash boil as adding it in.
I kept all garlic out of the peppers/roux and put it all in with shrimp and sauteed for about 3-4 minutes.
I also only used 2lbs shrimp and it had plenty shrimp vs sauce.
Also, you weren't kidding about how much Old Bay it takes. Took twice as much as I initially thought to put in.
I also doused it with Louisiana Hot Sauce once in my bowl.
All in all, it was fantastic. 'Grats on putting this together 'Clams. This one will make a recipe card in my permanent box.