Allow me, gentlemen. Ice Cream Piano has been my obsession for the better part of the last week.
The little accidental on the "you" of "No one can hear you" and at that point in the melody throughout the rest of the song is so good. And the pickup at around 1:16 is absolutely vintage VW. And then in the second (third?) verse where the track gets a little more muted and you can hear the drums and rhythm guitar a little more -- so smooth. I've been messing around with it on the piano for the last couple days, and I was a little surprised that the melody is a lot simpler than i thought. I expected it to be a lot more complex. Good pop music, man.
First time I heard it (last Sunday) I remember thinking to myself "THIS is the Vampire Weekend I first started liking." I've liked some of their other styles, but Ice Cream Piano feels closest to the great songs from their debut album.