I think they could certainly decide some criteria for making the tourney. For instance, in football, they could just take the six big BCS conference champs, then add two at large teams. Then give them an 8 team playoff. Don't win your conference championship, don't make the NCAA football playoff. In basketball, it would be somewhat harder. How about a few criteria, though. 1. Win at least half your conference games 2. Finish in the top half of your conference 3. Use a blended poll (kind of like the BCS computer poll combo) and place within the top 50 teams that don't have automatic berths. Then prioritize the remaining criteria, or put together a blended formula based on strength of schedule, road record, 2nd half of season performance, etc. Again, that would help to define candidates and give the committee more guidance, as well as better explanations.