Natasha Bedingfield vs. Vanessa Carlton, Who Do You Got?

[pissclams]

if it came down to you only being able to listen to either Natasha Bedingfield vs. Vanessa Carlton and for the rest of your life you could only listen to one and not the other, who would it be?

very tough decisions.  let me know your thoughts, ok? 

u digg?   

[Pett]

Easy, Natasha. Strictly because Vanessa just has one good song (that piano one) and Natasha has like five. And "Pocket Full of Sunshine" was really catchy too FWIW.

I also would choose Natasha because I feel sorry that her brother came out with that hit song that sounded like he was a women...

[pissclams]

well i have to be honest with you, natasha was my pick too but i wanted to field some responses from the masses before interjecting my viewpoint/perspective.

natasha is also much, much, more beautiful.  but then again, vanessa was my first love, u digg? 

[Butt Fugly]

 

[Applejack]

Natasha has an english accent which easily puts her over the top. 

[ECN]

 

not a fan of this one. a bit full of herself and her one song is SO annoying. her face reminds me of a horse. a horse who can play piano in the back of a car or whatever it was. she hauled that dumb piano around like it didnt take 7 underpaid guys a full weekend to do.

NatBed (as i like to call her) is super pretty. not looking like a horse and having underpaid interns to haul around a piano FTW!

[willie83]

Actually, they are both kind of horsey looking. I would go with Vanessa for listening stuff, not really into dance music.

[ECN]

OMG> she is totally nasty in that pic. for realz.

 

[Pete]

I haven't heard of either one of these people.  Can you compare and contrast each of them relative to Taylor Swift?

[Butt Fugly]

Swift>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Everyone else

[fatty fat fat]

prefer natalie imbruglia

[Perry]

Who? 

[pissclams]

prefer natalie imbruglia

she's on my ipod too brau, was saving her for the next round to take on the winner of the NB vs. VC match up.

I haven't heard of either one of these people.  Can you compare and contrast each of them relative to Taylor Swift?

pete, i'll bring my ipod to the katpak tonight.  u digg?   

[Pete]

Juice Newton was a fav of my growing up.  But, get this I thought she was saying "...just brush my teeth before you leave me..."  Turns out that is not what she is saying.  I thought the song was about a paraplegic and her care giver.

[Fledermaus]

I know I'm all but doesn't this belong in the "things you like but 90% of the world doesn't care about" thread?

[Pett]

prefer natalie imbruglia

"Torn" & "Wrong Impression" are instant classics.

[PCR]

Love both Bedingfields, but Natasha is super caliente.  Vanessa's one song was okay, especially when she sang it on Late World with Zach, but she's a chubby one-hit-wonder. 

She does look like she needs a hedgeapple between those choppers, though:

[Ben Ji 2.0]

Liy Allen. Case Closed

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPmH1fzZ-zk