I'm sorry.... nothing at any chain eatery is anywhere near as good as a good piece of homemade (or at a small town ma and pa place) pie.
I'd go with blueberry, cherry, pecan, sour cream raisin, peanut butter
Close follow-ups: peach, apricot, apple, chocolate cream (lots of meringue)
Not even on the list: mincemeat
Yeah mincemeat is the only pie i'd refuse a piece of.
As far as pie goes...
First tier - Dixie (derby, or oaks - just like pecan pie but w/ chocolate), pecan, custard pie, strawberry rhubarb, peach, peanut butter
2nd tier - cherry, lemon meringue, any kind of berry (blueberry, blackberry, etc), sour cream raisin
third tier - apple (most wtf overrated pie that everyone thinks their mom/grandma makes the best of), chocolate cream, banana cream, coconut cream