Knowing that I would go to grad school straight out of undergrad before I chose a school, the prestigiousness of my undergrad wouldn't really be an issue. It is name on your latest degree that usually matters most. So obviously any reasonable sports fan who could go back in time and pick a school to attend, would choose the institution where their fanhood would grow largest. Thus, I would choose the school that was most successful in sports over the time period I was in college...For me ('03-'07) I would've gone to Florida or USC for obvious reasons.