WHY NOT MAYO OVER ROSE?

[michigancat]

Still an honorary Wild Cat, IMO.

[PoetWarrior]

Legitimate question.

[yoman]

mayo has much more upside than rose. rose over beasley is just stupid

[Trim]

Character issues.

[doom]

Position and demand simply. 

[catdude33]

Rose is going to be a BUST in the NBA.  I honestly believe this to be true.

[FHSU92]

According to Doug Gottlealapodibad, Rose has >>>>>>> skill than Mayo.  Rose = superstar; Mayo = solid talent.

Don't any of you listen to effin' KMAN.  Leave TWC and the radar alone and listen to the Walters' Sportaganza.

DG said Rose over Beaz -- PG's more valuable; he couldn't let go of the fact that MB said he "wanted to win" yet went to KSU vs UCLA/UNC - gave cred to Mayo for being honestly greedy/egocentric; 5 schools/7 yrs.  Did say that give what MB had to work with (stellar supporting cast and vastly experienced coach -- for Rose that is), MB's accomplishments should be taken more seriously.

[blackman-era-front-rower]

be careful what you say... from what i'm hearing... it might be rose to chicago, mayo to miami and then beasley

[doom]

Rose is going to be a BUST in the NBA.  I honestly believe this to be true.

Not a bust.  More like a mid-card guy like Heinrich.  He could be a star, but I think it's all been overblown.

[phagallenblowsballs]

Rose is going to be a BUST in the NBA.  I honestly believe this to be true.

Not a bust.  More like a mid-card guy like Heinrich.  He could be a star, but I think it's all been overblown.

He'll be better than Heinrich....simply because of the race factor..

[KSU4ME]

Heinrich is taller and a better shooter.

[phagallenblowsballs]

Heinrich is taller and a better shooter.

No he isnt, they are both around 6'2"-6'3" range, and if anything Rose is more stronger and faster and younger.

And lets not act like Heinrich is some sort of sharpshooter either, I wouldnt exactly say shooting 40% from the field and 34% from 3 is "lights out".  But by Clent Stewart standards it would be.   

[KSU4ME]

Rose is under 6'2", according to the draft measurements.

And Rose was a significantly worse shooter in college, especially long range, than Heinrich.

Heck, Beasley was a much better 3 pt shooter than Rose.

[Bhyaaaaa!]

Heinrich is def a crap shooter for a white guy.

[phagallenblowsballs]

Rose is under 6'2", according to the draft measurements.

And Rose was a significantly worse shooter in college, especially long range, than Heinrich.

Heck, Beasley was a much better 3 pt shooter than Rose.

Ok so they are within an inch...at least Rose doesnt have those teenage ginger girl arms like Heinlicker...

Rose WILL be an above average PG, the same cannot be said about Heinrich...he'll always be average AT BEST!  The bulls knew they f'd by giving him that much bank...now he is pretty much untradable.

[greatjhawk]

Heinrich is taller and a better shooter.

and slower and less athletic and less potential.  Rose can still develop a jumper, Heinrich has peaked IMO.

But besides all that..........

[KSU4ME]

I'm sure you were saying the same things about Heinrich when he was drafted.

All college kids will improve in the NBA, right?

[phagallenblowsballs]

I'm sure you were saying the same things about Heinrich when he was drafted.

All college kids will improve in the NBA, right?

Damn buddy, you got a little crush on Heinrich or what?

Even the ku fans are taking Rose over him.

[KSU4ME]

No, I just remember what people thought of Rose before the Sweet Sixteen.

[honk4tad]

Derek Rows > kurt Heinrich