I did some quick research and found the haven game I think you're referring to. According to this group the victim was Sylvia, not St John.
Game - One Team
256 Haven, KS vs. Sylvia, KS, 11-16, 1927
233 Staunton, IL vs.
Gillespie, IL, 11-23, 1923
219 Stigler, OK vs. Ft. Gibson, OK, 1924
216 Muskegon, MI vs.
Hastings, MI, 9-28, 1912
201 Cozad, NE vs. Overton, NE, 1921
193 Kingsport Dobyns-Bennett, TN vs.
Norton Burton, VA, 1926
186 Spur, TX vs. Lorenzo, TX, 1930
185 Taylorville, IL vs. Tuscola, IL, 1916
184 Salem, IL vs. Fairfield, IL, 10-8, 1943
184 Roby, TX vs. Aspermont, TX, 1925