March Madness 08 or NCAA Hoops 2K8?

[kougar24]

I'm having trouble coming up with Christmas ideas, and games are easy. Especially sports games. So which one? Come on gamers, come through for me.

[ChicagoCat]

I dont know about this years in particular but I think 2k8 is usually far better year in/year out.

[cireksu]

yeah, thencaa games are usually the best.

[cas]

I went with 2K8 for the last few years, it has pretty good gameplay but it gets boring/repetitive after awhile. The game itself is somewhat unrealistic. (7'0 SF are common)

[kougar24]

I went with 2K8 for the last few years, it has pretty good gameplay but it gets boring/repetitive after awhile. The game itself is somewhat unrealistic. (7'0 SF are common)

I won't play that much, so that won't be a problem.

[QuinnMac]

2K8 hands down

[kstater7]

2K8 is amazing this year. You can download real rosters for free with the 2K Share feature, it's the best basketball game I've ever played.

[kougar24]

You can download real rosters for free with the 2K Share feature

Really? That's tight. Do I have to have a Live account (I mean, beyond the free "silver" one, or whatever)?