Couple things in reference to the MoCat/ FSD back and forth....
1) Reds were 20 out in the Division and 11.0 back of WC2 spot when they traded Cueto
2) Lamb and Reed haven't been good at all since they left here 2 years ago.
Reed has appeared in 17 MLB games, 11 as a starter. ERA of 7.15, WHIP of 1.77.
27 starts in the minors for him, an ERA of 3.45
Lamb had 24 MLB starts. ERA at 6.17, WHIP of 1.60, 12 minor league starts in 16'-17' with 6.48 ERA. He's not even with the Reds anymore and has not pitched in a MLB game this season
Finnegan has had some success. ERA of 4.48 in 37 Appearances (35 as starter) in 16'-17'. However, injuries have now begun to happen. He had an injury to a rotator cuff muscle that landed him on DL twice this year. He also had another injury and had surgery to repair a torn labrum in his shoulder. Just 13.0 Innings pitched in 2017.