i haven't paid much attention to bball outside the big 12, but i have a hard time accepting that osu at 9-9 is definitely in the tournament. they beat a lot of poor to average teams by large margins in the pre-season, garnering a gaudy kenpom rating. but they didn't actually beat many good teams (1-1 v memphis is really all they have, maybe include colorado if you think they can finish strong). .500 in the big 12 with very little in the non-con isn't on the bubble? i find that very difficult to believe.
They were 12-1 in non con. They beat Colorado when they were at full strength (Leading scorer Dinwiddie now done for year) and playing well. Memphis is probably about a 6 seed right now. That's 2 decent wins. Both are in top 30 RPI.
To compare, my current 9 seeds (VCU, Gonz, Stan, Xav) have 3 combined Top 50 wins in the non con. My 10 seeds (Cal, SMU, Colo, Minn) have 2 Top 50 wins in the non con. Right now the 9-11 seeds just are not that strong. I am sure there will be people that disagree with me, but I think OK St is still in the 8-9 seed range right now.
Big 12 being rated #1 conference could go a long ways to helping. Big 10 last year was stronger than Big 12 this year, but Minn lost 11 of last 16 and went 8-10, lost only B10 tourney game.... and they still got in as an 11 seed
If Osu goes 9-9, I will be shocked if they don't make it. Whether they make it to 9-9 is the big question. Looks tough right now. If they finish up at 8-10 they likely are gonna be 3-7 vs the Big 12 teams in the top 50. At that point, it just depends on how weak those last 4 teams getting in really are. Minn was 4-7 vs Big 10 teams in top 50 and had 1 good non con victory last season