RANK THE GREATEST NFL QB'S OF ALL TIME!!!

[Demo158]

http://espn.go.com/sportsnation/post/_/id/9277972/nfl-greatest-quarterbacks

Here's how I had em'
1.Joe Montana

2.Dan Marino

3.Brett Favre

4.Peyton Manning

5.Steve Young

6.Tom Brady

7.Terry Bradshaw

8.Roger Staubach

9.Phil Simms

10.John Elway

11.Troy Aikman

12.Bart Starr

13.Drew Brees

14.Joe Namath

15.Warren Moon

16.Fran Tarkenton

17.Dan Fouts

18.Sammy Baugh

19.Bob Griese

20.Johnny Unitas

21.Otto Graham

[Demo158]

Here's how the rest of the nation has em ranked collectively so far...

1.Joe Montana

2.Peyton Manning

3.Dan Marino

4.Tom Brady

5.John Elway

6.Brett Favre

7.Johnny Unitas

8.Steve Young

9.Terry Bradshaw

10.Troy Aikman

11.Bart Starr

12.Drew Brees

13.Roger Staubach

14.Phil Simms

15.Joe Namath

16.Warren Moon

17.Fran Tarkenton

18.Otto Graham

19.Sammy Baugh

20.Dan Fouts

21.Bob Griese

[j-dub]

Elway's the best. No need to rank the rest.

[scottwildcat]

if Trent Green isn't on the list I won't even recognize it as a valid attempt.

[steve dave]

joe montana, john elway and dan marino would get cut first day if they played today in their prime. it was such a pud sport back then.

[scottwildcat]

joe montana, john elway and dan marino would get cut first day if they played today in their prime. it was such a pud sport back then.

thoughts on Trent Green sd?

[steve dave]

joe montana, john elway and dan marino would get cut first day if they played today in their prime. it was such a pud sport back then.

thoughts on Trent Green sd?

I dont' even know who that is

[Dugout DickStone]

1.  Bishop
2.  Grogan
3.  Dickey
4.  Klein
5.  Straw

[scottwildcat]

joe montana, john elway and dan marino would get cut first day if they played today in their prime. it was such a pud sport back then.

thoughts on Trent Green sd?

I dont' even know who that is

:(

[Cartierfor3]

Elway's the best. No need to rank the rest.

Would've been a badass right fielder too

[Emo EMAW]

Dan Marino is the best and it isn't even close.

[ednksu]

lulz at puds who put Elway near the top. 

[8manpick]

1. Freemaw
/list

[Rage Against the McKee]

1. Tom Brady
2. Aaron Rodgers
3. Payton Manning
4. Drew Brees
5. Brett Favre
6. Steve Young
7. Eli Manning
8. Kurt Warner
9. Ben Roethlisberger
10. John Elway

[8manpick]

1. Freemaw
/list

Edit: I think Jordy threw a pass once. Put him #2.

[j-dub]

lulz at puds who put Elway near the top.

would say dumbass outed, but that's already been well established..

so - dumbass confirmed.

[ednksu]

lulz at puds who put Elway near the top.

would say dumbass outed, but that's already been well established..

so - dumbass confirmed.

Talk to TD who made his career.

But hey, I wouldn't expect much from most people here to acknowledge the black guy.

[asava]

lulz at puds who put Elway near the top.

would say dumbass outed, but that's already been well established..

so - dumbass confirmed.

Talk to TD who made his career.

But hey, I wouldn't expect much from most people here to acknowledge the black guy.

TD made his superbowl dreams come true, not his career's legacy.

[Cartierfor3]

lulz at puds who put Elway near the top.

would say dumbass outed, but that's already been well established..

so - dumbass confirmed.

Talk to TD who made his career.

But hey, I wouldn't expect much from most people here to acknowledge the black guy.

the race card? really? that's what you're playing? you're only reinforcing J-Dub's Elway boner when you go about it in such a dumbass way.

[ednksu]

lulz at puds who put Elway near the top.

would say dumbass outed, but that's already been well established..

so - dumbass confirmed.

Talk to TD who made his career.

But hey, I wouldn't expect much from most people here to acknowledge the black guy.

TD made his superbowl dreams come true, not his career's legacy.

Disagree.  His legacy is entirely defined by his super bowls.  His legacy if he didn't win the super bowls would cement him as a good/great QB, hot a top 5.  No one sits backs and thinks about how John Elway was the prototype QB in pro football like they do with Marino for example.  Look at his first 3 super bowl trips, utter embarrassments for a QB.  Against the Pack he was around 50% with no TDs.
I'm sorry that isn't good enough for people to put him above a host of others players.

[ednksu]

lulz at puds who put Elway near the top.

would say dumbass outed, but that's already been well established..

so - dumbass confirmed.

Talk to TD who made his career.

But hey, I wouldn't expect much from most people here to acknowledge the black guy.

the race card? really? that's what you're playing? you're only reinforcing J-Dub's Elway boner when you go about it in such a dumbass way.

LOL at anyone who doesn't recognize that black running backs aren't seen as replaceable and not worthy of the same commemoration as white QBs by the NFL, especially in these types of situations.

[jmlynch1]

Tom Brady is GOAT at QBing and just Being

[mocat]

Tom Brady is GOAT at QBing and just Being

Great post

[Asteriskhead]

TD didn't receive a bunch of post career recognition because of his career ending injuries. I think it's widely accepted, had he played a full career (whatever that means), he would have been recognized as one of the top 3 professional running backs of all time, but wish in one hand and crap in the other.

GMAFB with that argument. Elway is a top ten QB with or without TD.

(Davis is my all time favorite running back)

[Cartierfor3]

lulz at puds who put Elway near the top.

would say dumbass outed, but that's already been well established..

so - dumbass confirmed.

Talk to TD who made his career.

But hey, I wouldn't expect much from most people here to acknowledge the black guy.

the race card? really? that's what you're playing? you're only reinforcing J-Dub's Elway boner when you go about it in such a dumbass way.

LOL at anyone who doesn't recognize that black running backs aren't seen as replaceable and not worthy of the same commemoration as white QBs by the NFL, especially in these types of situations.

So just to be clear, the reason some view Elway as a better QB than Marino or Montana is because Terrell Davis is black. Great point numb nuts.