Who is arguing against that fan? I would question anyone who said that Angel didn't hurt this team in, a grand total of, 3 games.
The problem is even in the games Angel wasn't his best, he still made plenty of plays. Angel was a key in K-State coming back from an 18 point deficit.
And no one here has acknowledged that Angel was the one who locked down Galloway in the 2nd half on defense. After 15 points in the 1st half Galloway made 4 FTs in the 2nd, mainly because of Angel's defense. So I'll concede that Angel struggled shooting and made some poor passes, but he was also a key reason K-State had a shot to win and didn't lose by 20.
I guess I would ask people to examine which they value more. A player making standard facilitation plays which every major D1 PG should make or a player who can good plays while absolutely hurting his team.
Put a "standard facilitation" PG (like Clent Stewart) on this team and we are maybe .500 (at best) in the Big 12. I'll take a playmaker at PG who occasionally makes mistakes every single time. I value that much more, and I'd say 90% of college coaches would agree. And the 10% that don't are getting fired soon.
Stewart was not a standard facilitation guard for 3/4 years. Huggs made him into a serviceable guard his last year, who really didn't impact things till later in the year. I think you are undervaluing him in order to make your point, especially when you say we would be .500 with Stew and a tournament team with Will, that is just absurd.
And its one thing for a player to make a few plays and screw a few up, I mean we're talking about an underclassmen, so its going to happen. The problem is that Angel's mistakes cluster around a very small few games. When those mistakes come, it hurts the entirety of the game. Whats worse, is that it happens in high value games.
At the end of the day Angel maturation curve has been STEEP for the vast majority of the season making great strides in all aspects of his game. The results speak for themselves. No one can argue we would be where we are with Will at the helm. It just bothers me that many members here are over valuing Angel now in reaction to what they want/think Angel will be, and reacting against Tuckist latent racism.