Concensus All-Americans I tracked down...
1992 Some punter guy
1995-96 *Chris Canty (not sure why the * in '96)
1997 Automatica
1998 Bishop, Allen, Kelly
1999 Marky mark...what happened to his kstatehd.tv career?
2002 Newman
2007 Jordy
2012 Predator, Judge, Junior, whatev
Also, I realize there are a few from pre '88 but I'm not doing the research