I forgot how bad some 90s music was, so I googled it. After reviewing the top 100 songs of the 90s I can't decide between these 3:
Counting Crows: Big Yellow Taxi
Spin Doctors: Two Princes
Spin Doctors: Little Miss Can't Be Wrong
Note: I left out "Truely Madly Deeply" and "I Love You Always Forever" (#2 and #4 of the 90s) because I don't think either of those qualify as a song.