best cookie

['taterblast]

can't beat chocolate chip, imo

[pissclams]

for those of you chocolate chip bros, this recipe is über alles
http://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1015819-chocolate-chip-cookies

i use maldon sea salt flakes as the finishing salt
also, it's best to make them kinda big, the cookie ball should be just a tad larger than a golf ball

[Emo EMAW]

Double Stuff Oreo

 

I take two and pop off one black part from each and toss them and smash the remaining together and then eat.  I will not eat just one regular Double Stuff Oreo.  There must be two.

Also, I do not like the MEGA STUFF.  The icing seems different, more mushy.

 

Did we just become best friends!?

rough ridin' lib really left me hanging here.   

[Tobias]

wacky would call that "getting chingon'd"

[WillieWatanabe]

winner

[Mrs. Gooch]

winner

[AbeFroman]

Peanut butter oreos

[Pete]

I have been waiting patiently to chime in on this thread, because of the high volume of incorrect information I thought it best to break my silence on this topic.

I eat cookies roughly once a week, sometimes twice, on the weekends.  When I do, I go hard.

I work out probably more than most at this point (you should see me naked), and I like to have cookies (among other things) as my reward on the weekends.  It's a big deal to me.

This coming weekend I am going to make the finest cookie known to man. The inside out Oreo....aka the Oreo Truffle.

http://dessert.betterrecipes.com/oreo-truffles-3.html



I hate everything about traditional no-bake cookies.  Cannot stand them.  However, while the Oreo Truffle is not baked by YOU, it has been baked.  You just reform it into a rough ridin' work of art!

If you really MUST cook something, then I suggest the White Chocolate Macadamia Nut cookie.  Savory, crunchy, rich, and sweet.  A special cookie indeed!

[pissclams]

sorry pete, but maybe you missed the fact that i already posted the best cookie recipe of all time earlier in this thread?

[Mrs. Gooch]

I do really like White Chocolate Macadamia Nut cookies.

[HerrSonntag]

winner

[pissclams]

[Pete]

Personally, I am not a berry and chocolate man, but I still love and respect you. 

[Pete]

Do zebra nutty little Debbie bars count as cookies?  I love those right now.

[The Big Train]

i get that its a chocolate strawberry oreo but can you describe the exact taste?

[slackcat]

pecan shortbread.

[pissclams]

pecan shortbread.

sure thing, grandma

[Katpappy]

Does Nutty Buddy count as a cookie, cause they are hands down the BEST! 

[_33]

Does Nutty Buddy count as a cookie, cause they are hands down the BEST! 

Not a cookie, plus not even as good as Nutter Butters which is a cookie.

To answer the OP the best cookie is Oatmeal Scotchie.