What's so strange about those criteria?
I guess they aren't strange other than the fact that they seem chosen solely to support your argument.
Also, I think we're on the same page regarding recruiting/roster management. Though I'm not hopeful for either to improve in the near future under Frank.
What do you base this on? His recruiting has improved and the strategy has evolved, especially since 2010. He would have definitely missed a guy like Gipson or Upshaw in the past. I'm hopeful he has learned that his spring Juco additions have been absolute garbage and added nothing at all.