goemaw.com
TITLETOWN - A Decade Long Celebration Of The Greatest Achievement In College Athletics History => Kansas State Football => Topic started by: HamBoned on December 10, 2015, 07:32:19 PM
-
:dunno:
-
Come on over bud!
-
Loser.
Come on over.
-
Team cancer etc
-
(https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/f8/b0/62/f8b06224a749345b2875a5ad7ff84e2f.gif)
-
:spracne:
-
Kyle Allen from A&M is transferring as well.
-
Why are we getting our hopes up wishing for QB's from teams we normally beat. :whistle1:
-
I'd take both QB's in a heartbeat, but every time there's been good quarterbacks transferring out that have shown interest, we usually don't land them. So I'm not going to get my hopes up.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Trevor Knight is well suited for our system. Would take, hard
-
I'd take both QB's in a heartbeat, but every time there's been good quarterbacks transferring out that have shown interest, we usually don't land them. So I'm not going to get my hopes up.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I'm in the exact same boat.
-
There's never been a transfer that ever made sense tho. At least in the last 4 years.
-
Trevor Knight is well suited for our system. Would take, hard
christmas wish ... trevor knight sending snyder out on top, and venables take over afterwards. if venables doesn't take over for snyder, i think i'd shed too many tears for a grown ass man :crossfingers:
-
I'd take both QB's in a heartbeat, but every time there's been good quarterbacks transferring out that have shown interest, we usually don't land them. So I'm not going to get my hopes up.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I'm in the exact same boat.
The last one to show interest in us and burn us was Masoli, forever ago
-
http://www.bringonthecats.com/2015/12/10/9889640/qb-trevor-knight-granted-full-release-by-okahoma-considering-kansas?_ga=1.226910238.222447875.1363504849
Dreiling thinks hes interested
-
I could give a eff what Tyler Dreiling says
-
I could give a eff what Tyler Dreiling says
Agreed.
-
Trevor Knight is well suited for our system. Would take, hard
-
I'd take both QB's in a heartbeat, but every time there's been good quarterbacks transferring out that have shown interest, we usually don't land them. So I'm not going to get my hopes up.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I'm in the exact same boat.
My mind is in that boat, but my heart is sailing off in a different direction.
Gonna win 'em all!
-
I could give a eff what Tyler Dreiling says
why don't you then
-
lol @ him following Klein...
-
Klein recruiting sounds awful
-
Klein recruiting sounds awful
How so?!
-
socially awkward
-
socially awkward
Have you met him?
-
yes
-
I mean, he was a Heisman finalist. I would think recruits would listen to him. :dunno:
-
I mean, he was a Heisman finalist. I would think recruits would listen to him. :dunno:
They do... Waters.
-
I mean, he was a Heisman finalist. I would think recruits would listen to him. :dunno:
They do... Waters.
I know!!! :Woohoo:
-
yes
Maybe he didn't like you. I mean, just by your performance on this board, i'm sure he wanted to mush you away. Also, maybe since you weren't a QB recruit, he didn't feel like he had to be on around you. I mean, Currie last week, was kinda like "who the eff is this guy" when My guy introduced me to him and he looked like he could give two effs. I don't blame him for it. I didn't really give two effs either. He was in my view of the game.
-
Hey wacky, where were your seats at for the WV game?
-
Hey wacky, where were your seats at for the WV game?
Nice tap out.
-
quit obsessing over me bruh
-
I wonder if Stoops would be open to Knight joining Baylor, TCU, OSU or even UT? I think he would be welcomed at any of those schools. I think UT would benefit most, but Knight would give K-State 2 years to develop the next QB.
Interestingly I remember when the rumors started that Baker Mayfield would transfer to OU as a walk on, the fans here in Oklahoma scoffed at the idea that he could beat out Trevor Knight. It would be poetic justice for Knight to transfer and start at another Big 12 school and hand OU a loss next year.
-
I wonder if Stoops would be open to Knight joining Baylor, TCU, OSU or even UT? I think he would be welcomed at any of those schools. I think UT would benefit most, but Knight would give K-State 2 years to develop the next QB.
Interestingly I remember when the rumors started that Baker Mayfield would transfer to OU as a walk on, the fans here in Oklahoma scoffed at the idea that he could beat out Trevor Knight. It would be poetic justice for Knight to transfer and start at another Big 12 school and hand OU a loss next year.
Knight only has one year of eligibility left, not two.
Also, do not want. He was great vs. Bama in the Sugar Bowl and since then has been nothing more than mediocre -- 6-4 as a starter last year and struggled a lot in his only game with meaningful time this year (TCU). He would probably be asked to do different things in Dimel's offense and he could add depth to the QB position, but I'm not so sure that he would be the starter next season.
If he can't come in and be the clear #1 guy then I don't want him.
-
I wonder if Stoops would be open to Knight joining Baylor, TCU, OSU or even UT? I think he would be welcomed at any of those schools. I think UT would benefit most, but Knight would give K-State 2 years to develop the next QB.
Interestingly I remember when the rumors started that Baker Mayfield would transfer to OU as a walk on, the fans here in Oklahoma scoffed at the idea that he could beat out Trevor Knight. It would be poetic justice for Knight to transfer and start at another Big 12 school and hand OU a loss next year.
Knight only has one year of eligibility left, not two.
Also, do not want. He was great vs. Bama in the Sugar Bowl and since then has been nothing more than mediocre -- 6-4 as a starter last year and struggled a lot in his only game with meaningful time this year (TCU). He would probably be asked to do different things in Dimel's offense and he could add depth to the QB position, but I'm not so sure that he would be the starter next season.
If he can't come in and be the clear #1 guy then I don't want him.
With our style of offense. We can use all the depth we can get at the QB position. This year was a major wake up call.
-
I wonder if Stoops would be open to Knight joining Baylor, TCU, OSU or even UT? I think he would be welcomed at any of those schools. I think UT would benefit most, but Knight would give K-State 2 years to develop the next QB.
Interestingly I remember when the rumors started that Baker Mayfield would transfer to OU as a walk on, the fans here in Oklahoma scoffed at the idea that he could beat out Trevor Knight. It would be poetic justice for Knight to transfer and start at another Big 12 school and hand OU a loss next year.
Knight only has one year of eligibility left, not two.
Also, do not want. He was great vs. Bama in the Sugar Bowl and since then has been nothing more than mediocre -- 6-4 as a starter last year and struggled a lot in his only game with meaningful time this year (TCU). He would probably be asked to do different things in Dimel's offense and he could add depth to the QB position, but I'm not so sure that he would be the starter next season.
If he can't come in and be the clear #1 guy then I don't want him.
You are right.... Why bother trying to get decent quarterbacks when we can just find a random junior varsity kansas qb much easier.
-
It won't happen, but I'd take him in a heartbeat. You'd be kidding yourself if you wouldn't take him either. Then we could redshirt Delton, and have Cali Love + Hubes be 2 and 3 back ups. Imagine a already two year seasoned Delton taking the reigns as a RS Sophomore and owning souls for 3 years :love:
-
It won't happen, but I'd take him in a heartbeat. You'd be kidding yourself if you wouldn't take him either. Then we could redshirt Delton, and have Cali Love + Hubes be 2 and 3 back ups. Imagine a already two year seasoned Delton taking the reigns as a RS Sophomore and owning souls for 3 years :love:
You're forgetting about the stud QB that we just recruited this year.
-
It won't happen, but I'd take him in a heartbeat. You'd be kidding yourself if you wouldn't take him either. Then we could redshirt Delton, and have Cali Love + Hubes be 2 and 3 back ups. Imagine a already two year seasoned Delton taking the reigns as a RS Sophomore and owning souls for 3 years :love:
You're forgetting about the stud QB that we just recruited this year.
Then we have a happy problem then, and another Sams-Waters fight on our hands.
-
It won't happen, but I'd take him in a heartbeat. You'd be kidding yourself if you wouldn't take him either. Then we could redshirt Delton, and have Cali Love + Hubes be 2 and 3 back ups. Imagine a already two year seasoned Delton taking the reigns as a RS Sophomore and owning souls for 3 years :love:
Delton will probably use up his RS season with a medical RS for this past season. He'll have 4 to play 4. Same thing either way I suppose.
-
There's never been a transfer that ever made sense tho. At least in the last 4 years.
Are you saying at QB, or any position?
-
There's never been a transfer that ever made sense tho. At least in the last 4 years.
Are you saying at QB, or any position?
At QB. We've had a solid string of starters at Qb since Klein, until this year.
-
There's never been a transfer that ever made sense tho. At least in the last 4 years.
Are you saying at QB, or any position?
At QB. We've had a solid string of starters at Qb since Klein, until this year.
:dubious:
but I can agree partly. now if you were talking about any position, man was I gonna lay the smackdown
-
Well, you're just going to have to get over your butthurt for Waters. If we were talking position players, I would have demanded WR's and RB's ASAP!
-
Whoa, who said anything about Waters. Obsess much :lol:
-
Whoa, who said anything about Waters. Obsess much :lol:
Well, it was pretty apparent with the :dubious: look and that you "partly" agree. :gocho:
-
;)
-
The :dubious: was for your use of "string of QB's". One is not a string
-
I'm getting pretty pissed off at people treating Trevor Knight like he's Cam Newton. Stop telling other posters that they're fools or idiots for not wanting this dude. Some of you guys want to be thirsty for a dude benched, fine do that but stop acting like this guy is done savior when Russell Wilson was the only grad transfer QB in the history of the world that actually worked out.
-
I'm getting pretty pissed off at people treating Trevor Knight like he's Cam Newton. Stop telling other posters that they're fools or idiots for not wanting this dude. Some of you guys want to be thirsty for a dude benched, fine do that but stop acting like this guy is done savior when Russell Wilson was the only grad transfer QB in the history of the world that actually worked out.
So you are saying we're due! :excited:
-
hey look MIR is pissed about something :horrorsurprise:
-
I'm getting pretty pissed off at people treating Trevor Knight like he's Cam Newton. Stop telling other posters that they're fools or idiots for not wanting this dude. Some of you guys want to be thirsty for a dude benched, fine do that but stop acting like this guy is done savior when Russell Wilson was the only grad transfer QB in the history of the world that actually worked out.
Who says he's Cam Newton? And who the hell on our roster right now is better than he is? Sorry he got benched for Baker Mayfield, I'll make sure to send my condolences to him. GMAFB.
hey look MIR is pissed about something :horrorsurprise:
Sun rises in the east, water is wet.
-
Don't even know why need to emotional about this anyways, not like he's coming here.
-
hey look MIR is pissed about something :horrorsurprise:
hey look meow meow is doing his unconfident loser with no original thoughts thing again :zzz:
-
hey look MIR is pissed about something :horrorsurprise:
hey look meow meow is doing his unconfident loser with no original thoughts thing again :zzz:
eff yeah bruh, unconfident losers are the best!
-
I'm getting pretty pissed off at people treating Trevor Knight like he's Cam Newton. Stop telling other posters that they're fools or idiots for not wanting this dude. Some of you guys want to be thirsty for a dude benched, fine do that but stop acting like this guy is done savior when Russell Wilson was the only grad transfer QB in the history of the world that actually worked out.
I think most folks here are just excited about anyone who could drop Hubes a little lower on the depth chart.
-
1) Knight was decent, but not a great QB at OU.
2) If he wants to come to K-State and compete for a spot there is no reason not to let him have a shot.
-
The next Russell Wilson :excited:
-
Can't see him coming to Manhattan.
He'd be better off going to the C-USA or the WAC.
-
Jeff Driskel kind of beat our ass a little, maybe add that to the list?
-
>
I'm getting pretty pissed off at people treating Trevor Knight like he's Cam Newton. Stop telling other posters that they're fools or idiots for not wanting this dude. Some of you guys want to be thirsty for a dude benched, fine do that but stop acting like this guy is done savior when Russell Wilson was the only grad transfer QB in the history of the world that actually worked out.
Now, imagine that quarterback. . . isn't white
#mcconaughay
-
We started a qb all year that never started in high school, yeah we should definitely tell Knight to piss off.
-
I'm getting pretty pissed off at people treating Trevor Knight like he's Cam Newton. Stop telling other posters that they're fools or idiots for not wanting this dude. Some of you guys want to be thirsty for a dude benched, fine do that but stop acting like this guy is done savior when Russell Wilson was the only grad transfer QB in the history of the world that actually worked out.
vernon adams was pretty great at oregon this year. if he wouldn't have broken his finger/been concussed, oregon wins the pac 12 again.
-
I'm getting pretty pissed off at people treating Trevor Knight like he's Cam Newton. Stop telling other posters that they're fools or idiots for not wanting this dude. Some of you guys want to be thirsty for a dude benched, fine do that but stop acting like this guy is done savior when Russell Wilson was the only grad transfer QB in the history of the world that actually worked out.
vernon adams was pretty great at oregon this year. if he wouldn't have broken his finger/been concussed, oregon wins the pac 12 again.
Yeah he did very well as the season progressed
-
you have to be an absolute Fake Sugar Dick (WARNING, NOT THE REAL SUGAR DICK!) to not want him at ksu.
worst case extra depth.
best case, the 10% chance he figures crap out and plays to his potential.
-
you have to be an absolute respect to not want him at ksu.
worst case extra depth.
best case, the 10% chance he figures crap out and plays to his potential.
Do I want his talents in Manhattan? Absolutely.
The problem I see of Knight is he is made out of glass. There's always some kind of injuries going on with this kid, and you combine that with Snyder's offense, well....
-
you have to be an absolute respect to not want him at ksu.
worst case extra depth.
best case, the 10% chance he figures crap out and plays to his potential.
Do I want his talents in Manhattan? Absolutely.
The problem I see of Knight is he is made out of glass. There's always some kind of injuries going on with this kid, and you combine that with Snyder's offense, well....
Ertz was our starting QB
-
you have to be an absolute respect to not want him at ksu.
worst case extra depth.
best case, the 10% chance he figures crap out and plays to his potential.
Do I want his talents in Manhattan? Absolutely.
The problem I see of Knight is he is made out of glass. There's always some kind of injuries going on with this kid, and you combine that with Snyder's offense, well....
Ertz was our starting QB
That's my point. Ertz was our starting QB, injured.
Then assuming Knight comes in, plays, gets injured.
We're right back to Hubes....
-
you have to be an absolute respect to not want him at ksu.
worst case extra depth.
best case, the 10% chance he figures crap out and plays to his potential.
Do I want his talents in Manhattan? Absolutely.
The problem I see of Knight is he is made out of glass. There's always some kind of injuries going on with this kid, and you combine that with Snyder's offense, well....
Ertz was our starting QB
That's my point. Ertz was our starting QB, injured.
Then assuming Knight comes in, plays, gets injured.
We're right back to Hubes....
No. There's Delton, Cali Love, and Sky Thompson.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
you have to be an absolute respect to not want him at ksu.
worst case extra depth.
best case, the 10% chance he figures crap out and plays to his potential.
Do I want his talents in Manhattan? Absolutely.
The problem I see of Knight is he is made out of glass. There's always some kind of injuries going on with this kid, and you combine that with Snyder's offense, well....
Ertz was our starting QB
That's my point. Ertz was our starting QB, injured.
Then assuming Knight comes in, plays, gets injured.
We're right back to Hubes....
This is a terrible argument, btw. That's like saying "you shouldn't bother wearing a seatbelt, because if the seatbelt breaks you will still get hurt in a collision."
The point is Knight would still offer an additional layer of protection between us and the train wreck that is Joe Hubener.
-
You all realize we don't have to choose between Knight and someone else, right? We are just adding someone to our roster or not adding them. What is the downside to having him?
-
There is zero downside at all
-
upside is 'zooka has a smaller chance he will play
-
any guesses on his graduate track? My guess is grassland management.
-
You all realize we don't have to choose between Knight and someone else, right? We are just adding someone to our roster or not adding them. What is the downside to having him?
You think Ertz and/or Delton will stay here if they get recruited over for what would amount to be the 3rd time in less than a year? In Delton's case it would be the third time before you've had a chance to show what you can or can't do.
And as previously stated you are essentially trading a year of development of your young QBs for one season of a guy who presided over the worst season OU has had since 1999. It's cool though we'll just act like this entire board didn't spend all of last season mocking Knight. Jake Waters is absolutely a better QB, would you guys take another year of Waters starting over Delton or Thompson?
-
that bama game tho
-
OU averaged 36 points a game last year
-
Sometimes I think you guys just don't want to see the next couple years with our young developing QB, Pukea Joe taking the reins. Shame on you all! :fatty:
-
OU fired their offensive coordinator last year
-
OU's starting quarterback was 76th in passing efficiency last year
-
You all realize we don't have to choose between Knight and someone else, right? We are just adding someone to our roster or not adding them. What is the downside to having him?
You think Ertz and/or Delton will stay here if they get recruited over for what would amount to be the 3rd time in less than a year? In Delton's case it would be the third time before you've had a chance to show what you can or can't do.
And as previously stated you are essentially trading a year of development of your young QBs for one season of a guy who presided over the worst season OU has had since 1999. It's cool though we'll just act like this entire board didn't spend all of last season mocking Knight. Jake Waters is absolutely a better QB, would you guys take another year of Waters starting over Delton or Thompson?
They are freshmen! If they transfer because they aren't guaranteed the starting job as freshmen then they can kick rocks.
P.S. I don't care what Ertz does.
-
You think Ertz and/or Delton will stay here if they get recruited over for what would amount to be the 3rd time in less than a year? In Delton's case it would be the third time before you've had a chance to show what you can or can't do.
(https://s3.amazonaws.com/tapatalk-emoji/emoji38.png)
nice of you to look out for their feelings
-
Which quarterback would you take as a transfer?
QB A 179/316 2300 yds. 14 TDs 12 INTs 68 rushes for 339 yds 5 TDs
QB B 254/451 2669 yds. 18 TDs 9 INTs 125 rushes for 421 yds 3 TDs
Both guys got benched in 2015, both eligible for transfer. The one with clearly the worst stats is obviously Trevor Knight. Anyone without looking care to guess who QB B is? He's someone you all know and we'd all agree is someone we wouldn't want playing QB for us if it was at the expense of a QB we already have. He also didn't have a running back who holds the single game rushing game offering him cover in the same backfield.
-
Which quarterback would you take as a transfer?
QB A 179/316 2300 yds. 14 TDs 12 INTs 68 rushes for 339 yds 5 TDs
QB B 254/451 2669 yds. 18 TDs 9 INTs 125 rushes for 421 yds 3 TDs
Both guys got benched in 2015, both eligible for transfer. The one with clearly the worst stats is obviously Trevor Knight. Anyone without looking care to guess who QB B is? He's someone you all know and we'd all agree is someone we wouldn't want playing QB for us if it was at the expense of a QB we already have. He also didn't have a running back who holds the single game rushing game offering him cover in the same backfield.
I don't see bringing in a transfer with one year of eligibiity costing K-State a QB. If it does it's ridiculous. A 3/4* QB shouldn't expect the job as a freshman.
-
Which quarterback would you take as a transfer?
QB A 179/316 2300 yds. 14 TDs 12 INTs 68 rushes for 339 yds 5 TDs
QB B 254/451 2669 yds. 18 TDs 9 INTs 125 rushes for 421 yds 3 TDs
Both guys got benched in 2015, both eligible for transfer. The one with clearly the worst stats is obviously Trevor Knight. Anyone without looking care to guess who QB B is? He's someone you all know and we'd all agree is someone we wouldn't want playing QB for us if it was at the expense of a QB we already have. He also didn't have a running back who holds the single game rushing game offering him cover in the same backfield.
I don't see bringing in a transfer with one year of eligibiity costing K-State a QB. If it does it's ridiculous. A 3/4* QB shouldn't expect the job as a freshman.
At this point that is secondary. I didn't realize how amazingly average Trevor Knight was in 2014. He had numbers like that with Sterling Sheppard and Perine. He also had 2 offensive linemen and a fullback drafted from that offense. OU was loaded, how in the hell was he the 76th most efficient passer? QB B didn't have anyone on his offense drafted, let's go get that guy.
-
crap, breaking news, quarterback b is not transfer eligible after all. Damn :cry:
-
LOL @ MIR I'm sure OU's problems last year were all on Knight. OU fans were bitching up a storm about Huepel.
-
Who was QB B?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Ou s offense was terrible, knight would be incredible running our qb run game
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Who was QB B?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
HINT: the use of quarterback "B" was not unintentional
-
Guys, it's obvious we need to tell him to get mumped to save the scholarship for one of the 4 or 5 stars we have lined up.
-
I remember a few years back a bunch of dumbasses were all Arthur Brown's stats sucked at the U, which has a shitty defense, it would be totally stupid to allow him to transfer in because 3-star stud Blake Slaughter might want to transfer. Guess, what, Blake didn't transfer.
-
I remember a few years back a bunch of dumbasses were all Arthur Brown's stats sucked at the U, which has a shitty defense, it would be totally stupid to allow him to transfer in because 3-star stud Blake Slaughter might want to transfer. Guess, what, Blake didn't transfer.
Except no one said that
-
I remember a few years back a bunch of dumbasses were all Arthur Brown's stats sucked at the U, which has a shitty defense, it would be totally stupid to allow him to transfer in because 3-star stud Blake Slaughter might want to transfer. Guess, what, Blake didn't transfer.
Except no one said that
:mindblown:
Seriously, we have no class balance at QB. Bringing in a senior is a really good idea. If Delton is better, he'll ultimately start. If you think Hubes, Ertz or Banks are anything more than backups at this juncture, you are a lunatic. Those 3 each almost certainly understand that to be their role.
The idea that bringing in a transfer (as opposed to any other recruit) could cause a player to feel slighted is incredibly stupid and childish given 25 new guys are brought in every rough ridin' season in cfb. It's about as stupid as thinking Jones would feel cheated when Dimel got goal line carries.
Delton/Thompson are the only two that may cause the other to transfer.
-
i dont think trevor knight is an upgrade over alex delton
-
1. it's kind of weird after a season like we just had to be against adding veteran, non-former-walkon-wide-receiver qb depth
2. if delton or ertz transfer because of it (i don't think they would) and have to sit out at another school during the only year knight will be here, then they are stupid
-
the only reason im against it is because he is a known locker room cancer
-
Who was QB B?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
HINT: the use of quarterback "B" was not unintentional
Nice job wetwillie. The qb with better numbers than the great Trevor Knight is Iowa State's own Sam B. Richardson. Something tells me that we wouldn't be so enthusiastic if we wanted to transfer here with assurances he'd start.
Ou s offense was terrible, knight would be incredible running our qb run game
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
He couldn't run OUs offense with NFL talent all over the field. He wouldn't have 4 NFL O-linemen and Sheppard and Perine here, doesn't that concern you? Or does one good game 2 years ago and Katy Perry saying his name on college gameday matter more?
-
Not sure, but I'm guessing we'd wouldn't ask knight to run the run and shoot offense
-
the only reason im against it is because he is a known locker room cancer
Based on OU's performance this year, I'd be ok with that kind of cancer.
-
the only reason im against it is because he is a known locker room cancer
Based on OU's performance this year, I'd be ok with that kind of cancer.
I think he was voted a team captain alongside Mayfield :dunno:
-
I want him bad
-
Our returning QB's consist of:
1- a guy who is coming off major knee surgery and played 2 snaps, was a 2* out of HS
2-a qb who has proven he is absolutely nothing special and below average at best and was in some games replaced by a WR
3-see #1 but with a few more snaps and not as bad of an injury and was a 3*
4-a juco kid who couldn't beat out a WR to play QB
5-some HS recruit
and you guys are arguing over whether Trevor is good enough for us?
-
I mean, we aren't Baylor talking about if he would be a good fit. We are a team who was realistically going to have Charles jones playing full time QB if our WR that was playing QB at the time was injured.
-
Our returning QB's consist of:
1- a guy who is coming off major knee surgery and played 2 snaps, was a 2* out of HS
2-a qb who has proven he is absolutely nothing special and below average at best and was in some games replaced by a WR
3-see #1 but with a few more snaps and not as bad of an injury and was a 3*
4-a juco kid who couldn't beat out a WR to play QB
5-some HS recruit
and you guys are arguing over whether Trevor is good enough for us?
I seem to be the only person arguing against him and whether or not he's "good enough for us" isn't my argument at all. Also calling Skyler Thompson "some HS recruit" is unnecessarily disingenuous.
-
Having one of our young quarterbacks get a year of experience is infinitely more important than having Trevor Knight come in here and go 8-5 at best and then we have to go into 2017 having to groom another starting quarterback again, what would be our 4th in 4 years. We have a chance to develop some stability at the most important position in sports and Knight at K-State simply isn't good enough to bypass that. It is baffling to me that no one else can see that.
-
Our returning QB's consist of:
1- a guy who is coming off major knee surgery and played 2 snaps, was a 2* out of HS
2-a qb who has proven he is absolutely nothing special and below average at best and was in some games replaced by a WR
3-see #1 but with a few more snaps and not as bad of an injury and was a 3*
4-a juco kid who couldn't beat out a WR to play QB
5-some HS recruit
and you guys are arguing over whether Trevor is good enough for us?
I seem to be the only person arguing against him and whether or not he's "good enough for us" isn't my argument at all. Also calling Skyler Thompson "some HS recruit" is unnecessarily disingenuous.
It isn't disingenuous when you factor in that Bill has never started a true freshman despite having terrible alternatives. Skyler Thompson will be lucky to see the field by his redshirt sophomore year, if history shows us anything at all.
-
Bill will be dead or retired by then. No factor.
-
Why wouldn't we take him? If Delton or Ertz are better then fantastic, we have a great back up option when Ertz and Delton get hurt.
This is all moot, of course, because Trevor is absolutely not coming here.
-
This is all moot, of course, because Trevor is absolutely not coming here.
It's pretty much combofanning season. Nothing wrong with lol hypothetical debates.
-
Why wouldn't we take him? If Delton or Ertz are better then fantastic, we have a great back up option when Ertz and Delton get hurt.
This is all moot, of course, because Trevor is absolutely not coming here.
He's not coming here or anywhere else that can't/won't offer him assurances. Why don't you think he won't go to K-State? It's been reported that he and the coaches have had contact.
-
Why wouldn't we take him? If Delton or Ertz are better then fantastic, we have a great back up option when Ertz and Delton get hurt.
This is all moot, of course, because Trevor is absolutely not coming here.
He's not coming here or anywhere else that can't/won't offer him assurances. Why don't you think he won't go to K-State? It's been reported that he and the coaches have had contact.
Besides assuring Trevor that he will have to memorize the 16 principles, what else on earth do you honestly think our staff would ever assure him.
-
Concussions and shoulder surgeries
-
Concussions and shoulder surgeries
Sad, but true.
-
Why wouldn't we take him? If Delton or Ertz are better then fantastic, we have a great back up option when Ertz and Delton get hurt.
This is all moot, of course, because Trevor is absolutely not coming here.
He's not coming here or anywhere else that can't/won't offer him assurances. Why don't you think he won't go to K-State? It's been reported that he and the coaches have had contact.
Besides assuring Trevor that he will have to memorize the 16 principles, what else on earth do you honestly think our staff would ever assure him.
I certainly would hope that they wouldn't assure him the starting job, but Del and Dana never cease to amaze me and I don't mean that in a good way. From what I understand Thompson committed to Del so that gives me some hope that he wouldn't recruit the best high school QB prospect Snyder's staff has ever had and then tell some dude with 14 tds and 12 ints that he can come and start.
I do think that if they tell him that he can come here and start while they develop the young QBs, he's absolutely coming.
-
GOOD
-
I don't think Trevor (potentially) coming here has anything to do with Skylar playing (or not playing) next year. What could we have possibly promised Skylar about next year? That he would, at a minimum, be behind Ertz and Delton and Hubener?
-
Hopefully that's exactly what they told him
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Do we not have that rule any longer where you lose a year of eligibility if you transfer in conference?
-
Do we not have that rule any longer where you lose a year of eligibility if you transfer in conference?
Not a rule for 5th year guys
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
He's a graduate with eligibility left.
-
Didn't OU's current starter transfer from Tech? Did he lose a year?
-
I don't think he lost eligibility, just had to RS
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Didn't OU's current starter transfer from Tech? Did he lose a year?
that whole story is weird as eff
-
I hope we promise Knight the starting job and then break that promise if we have a better option next year.
-
I don't think he lost eligibility, just had to RS
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
He had to redshirt and wasn't allowed to be scholarshiped because Tech didn't release him. rough ridin' schools have way too much power over these kids.
-
I hope we promise Knight the starting job and then break that promise if we have a better option next year.
That'd be great
-
If Knight chooses to be a KSU crash test dummy, I'll think he's too stupid to play.
-
I don't think he lost eligibility, just had to RS
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
He had to redshirt and wasn't allowed to be scholarshiped because Tech didn't release him. rough ridin' schools have way too much power over these kids.
It was a pretty shitty thing that Kliff did to him.
-
I don't think Trevor (potentially) coming here has anything to do with Skylar playing (or not playing) next year. What could we have possibly promised Skylar about next year? That he would, at a minimum, be behind Ertz and Delton and Hubener?
Are we still talking about this because we don't want to acknowledge that he's probably not significantly better than what we have now? Jesus, I can't imagine how many picks and fumbles he'll have playing at OU next year, he might literally crap himself.
#6thYearForSamBInstead
-
Couldn't be any worse then the 55 zip beatdown we got this last year. Unless you're expecting Delton to lead us out of Norman with a win?
Without radical improvement across the board, we aren't beating OU in Norman next year or any time soon.
-
If Knight chooses to be a KSU crash test dummy, I'll think he's too stupid to play.
Amen brother.
-
(https://cdn0.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/njYS3L8I0wanUS5MlapjPVz3Mos=/cdn0.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/2367120/nooou.0.0.gif)
:frown:
-
(https://cdn0.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/njYS3L8I0wanUS5MlapjPVz3Mos=/cdn0.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/2367120/nooou.0.0.gif)
:frown:
He was born to throw EMAW touchdown passes.
-
That was such an awful throw. When i saw that live i could not believe he threw that.
-
What OC calls that play? Good thing they didn't pump and go.
-
I'm predicting he'll be headed to A&M, if the rumors from Aggieland are true they could be in a worse QB situation than we were this year
-
let's play another game of which qb would you rather have:
qb a: 262-397 66%, 3501 yards, 22 td, 7 int /// 154 carries, 484 yards, 9 td
qb b: 137-278 49%, 1666 yards, 13 td, 9 int /// 192 carries, 934 yards, 11 td
qb c: 131-274 48%, 1837 yards, 9 td, 9 int ///180 carries, 613 yards, 13 td
-
For our offense? QB2
-
QB A. Can't wait to see which bum that is tho.
-
QB A probably had receivers that could run routes and catch, tho.
-
For our offense? QB2
That's Hubs! :Wha:
-
QB A is Waters
QB B is Hubes
QB C ????
-
None of those QB are Knight, so what is the point of this exercise?
http://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/trevor-knight-1.html (http://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/trevor-knight-1.html)
TK's career stats:
280/490 (57%) for 3424 yds, 25 TD, 19 int
151 carries for 853 yds (5.6/att) and 9 TD
-
And Hubes is QB C, not B.
-
qb beta
-
B is #life this season.
-
A: Waters
B: Life
C: Hubes
-
B is #life this season.
:sdeek:
-
Comparing QB stats between the Big 12 and Southland is asinine.
-
I think stunted was a FAS baby or was a crack baby or something. Something doesn't quite fire right in his head.
-
More like something didn't fire right in #life's head loool amirite?
-
http://sports.yahoo.com/news/florida-qb-grier-decides-transfer-amid-ped-suspension-210320788--ncaaf.html
Would take
-
Wouldn't he actually eff up class balance, unlike Knight. Like someone would almost certainly need to transfer
-
he would never survive the hyper compliance environment of kstate athletics.
-
Wouldn't he actually eff up class balance, unlike Knight. Like someone would almost certainly need to transfer
No he's a redshirt freshman. He's one year older than Delton and two years older than Thompson.
-
a&m
-
Gay....
Kill this thread now. :flush:
-
The 5 million dollar man out recruited us
-
Gay....
Kill this thread now. :flush:
Woah, chill out chief.
He went where he knew he would play, no surprise at all.
-
Is anyone really surprised by his choice? A&M has a hot mess right now but one thing they clearly need is a QB and he wants to play.
-
didn't want to work hard, see u later lozer
-
didn't want to work hard, see u later lozer
The Structure does not yield to FPTC'ers
-
didn't want to work hard, see u later lozer
Or didn't want the life-long impact of repeated concussions :ksu: