goemaw.com

TITLETOWN - A Decade Long Celebration Of The Greatest Achievement In College Athletics History => Kansas State Basketball is hard => Topic started by: nicname on March 26, 2011, 11:26:47 PM

Title: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: nicname on March 26, 2011, 11:26:47 PM
Two years in a row in the final four.  These guys lost 9 times this year.  They lost to every good team they played.  They also lost to Valpo, got swept by Wisc. Milwaukee, etc.  How the hell can they turn it on in a win or go home tournament?  I don't get it.  Would they have this success in a 7 game playoff series?  OR do they just sleepwalk through their crappy conference?

WTF
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: jtksu on March 27, 2011, 12:14:40 AM
They didn't sleepwalk through their conference last year, did they?  I was thinking they only had like 4 losses?  Regardless, it doesn't really matter.  Just make sure you're playing your best ball when it counts, kinda like we did last year.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: pike on March 27, 2011, 12:17:35 AM
They didn't sleepwalk through their conference last year, did they?  I was thinking they only had like 4 losses?  Regardless, it doesn't really matter.  Just make sure you're playing your best ball when it counts, kinda like we did last year.

Yeah they were on like a 20 game win streak and ranked in the top 10 when we faced them, IIRC.

Stevens is BITB and has a very bright future.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: nicname on March 27, 2011, 12:43:58 AM
Yeah, I was more referring to their season this year.  They were solid last season. 
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: Cire on March 27, 2011, 01:27:34 AM
Elite defense.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: sys on March 27, 2011, 07:58:47 AM
extremely physical defense, outstanding screening, good shooters, ridiculously lucky.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: wetwillie on March 27, 2011, 08:15:59 AM
extremely physical defense, outstanding screening, good shooters, ridiculously lucky.

they had at least one opportunity for a 2-1 in the game against UF and didn't take it. I was pretty disappointed, thought for sure I'd see one with them.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: CNS on March 27, 2011, 08:39:27 AM
the awkward white kid with the lack of a haircut and who's jersey doesn't fit him.  He is BU this year.  He is like Energy, but minus the occasional hindrance, and plus the ability.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: PowercatPat on March 27, 2011, 09:03:54 AM
I was asking myself the same question. I think most of it is an unbelievable amount of luck. The first 2 rounds against ODU and especially Pitt are prime examples.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: CNS on March 27, 2011, 09:07:42 AM
I was asking myself the same question. I think most of it is an unbelievable amount of luck. The first 2 rounds against ODU and especially Pitt are prime examples.

The Pitt win was a sham. The foul with 1.4 seconds left was a horrible call.  That game should have been decided in OT.  The ref responsible should be given the post-St.John's treatment.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: sys on March 27, 2011, 09:11:54 AM
The Pitt win was a sham. The foul with 1.4 seconds left was a horrible call.  That game should have been decided in OT.  The ref responsible should be given the post-St.John's treatment.

it was absolutely the right call.  the pitt player grabbed his arm.  it's not a ref's job to save a player from his own stupidity.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: ChiComCat on March 27, 2011, 09:18:14 AM
The Pitt win was a sham. The foul with 1.4 seconds left was a horrible call.  That game should have been decided in OT.  The ref responsible should be given the post-St.John's treatment.

It was no better/worse than the call to send the Pitt player to the line.  I have no problems with it.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: CNS on March 27, 2011, 09:21:35 AM
The Pitt win was a sham. The foul with 1.4 seconds left was a horrible call.  That game should have been decided in OT.  The ref responsible should be given the post-St.John's treatment.

it was absolutely the right call.  the pitt player grabbed his arm.  it's not a ref's job to save a player from his own stupidity.

I recognize it was a foul.  However, it was a foul at the other end of the floor with 1.4 seconds left and the entire Pitt team between howard and the other goal 80' away.  If he got the rebound without incident, he had 0% chance to effect the game's outcome given position and time.  

Refs, coaches, and talking heads mention all the time in interviews how the refs hold the whistle on fouls at the end of the game unless they have an obvious impact on the game.  They usually don't want to help decide the game with a whistle.  If the exact same scenario played out on Butler's end of the court, I would be all for the call, but not on Pitt's end.  

Horrible call.  That ref decided the game due to a play that had no chance on deciding the game.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: ChiComCat on March 27, 2011, 09:26:34 AM
The Pitt win was a sham. The foul with 1.4 seconds left was a horrible call.  That game should have been decided in OT.  The ref responsible should be given the post-St.John's treatment.

it was absolutely the right call.  the pitt player grabbed his arm.  it's not a ref's job to save a player from his own stupidity.

I recognize it was a foul.  However, it was a foul at the other end of the floor with 1.4 seconds left and the entire Pitt team between howard and the other goal 80' away.  If he got the rebound without incident, he had 0% chance to effect the game's outcome given position and time. 

Refs, coaches, and talking heads mention all the time in interviews how the refs hold the whistle on fouls at the end of the game unless they have an obvious impact on the game.  They usually don't want to help decide the game with a whistle.  If the exact same scenario played out on Butler's end of the court, I would be all for the call, but not on Pitt's end. 

Horrible call.  That ref decided the game due to a play that had no chance on deciding the game.

I get the swallow the whistle thing, but the officials made it clear on the Butler foul at half court that they weren't going to be swallowing their whistles.  The reaction by Howard to sell the foul and get the call shows that he was smart enough to know this.  The Pitt player fouling was not.  Howard maybe made the best play of the tourny with that one.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: CNS on March 27, 2011, 09:28:17 AM
The Pitt win was a sham. The foul with 1.4 seconds left was a horrible call.  That game should have been decided in OT.  The ref responsible should be given the post-St.John's treatment.

it was absolutely the right call.  the pitt player grabbed his arm.  it's not a ref's job to save a player from his own stupidity.

I recognize it was a foul.  However, it was a foul at the other end of the floor with 1.4 seconds left and the entire Pitt team between howard and the other goal 80' away.  If he got the rebound without incident, he had 0% chance to effect the game's outcome given position and time. 

Refs, coaches, and talking heads mention all the time in interviews how the refs hold the whistle on fouls at the end of the game unless they have an obvious impact on the game.  They usually don't want to help decide the game with a whistle.  If the exact same scenario played out on Butler's end of the court, I would be all for the call, but not on Pitt's end. 

Horrible call.  That ref decided the game due to a play that had no chance on deciding the game.

I get the swallow the whistle thing, but the officials made it clear on the Butler foul at half court that they weren't going to be swallowing their whistles.  The reaction by Howard to sell the foul and get the call shows that he was smart enough to know this.  The Pitt player fouling was not.  Howard maybe made the best play of the tourny with that one.

I def don't hate howard for the flop.  Fully agree on that part.  Not my point.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: Clevey 2 Times on March 27, 2011, 09:30:03 AM
The Pitt win was a sham. The foul with 1.4 seconds left was a horrible call.  That game should have been decided in OT.  The ref responsible should be given the post-St.John's treatment.

it was absolutely the right call.  the pitt player grabbed his arm.  it's not a ref's job to save a player from his own stupidity.

I recognize it was a foul.  However, it was a foul at the other end of the floor with 1.4 seconds left and the entire Pitt team between howard and the other goal 80' away.  If he got the rebound without incident, he had 0% chance to effect the game's outcome given position and time.  

Refs, coaches, and talking heads mention all the time in interviews how the refs hold the whistle on fouls at the end of the game unless they have an obvious impact on the game.  They usually don't want to help decide the game with a whistle.  If the exact same scenario played out on Butler's end of the court, I would be all for the call, but not on Pitt's end.  

Horrible call.  That ref decided the game due to a play that had no chance on deciding the game.


 :facepalm:


Seriously.... :facepalm:
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: yoga-like_abana on March 27, 2011, 09:32:55 AM
He was fouled quit letting your inner tard get the best of you.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: Clevey 2 Times on March 27, 2011, 09:33:39 AM
Two years in a row in the final four.  These guys lost 9 times this year.  They lost to every good team they played.  They also lost to Valpo, got swept by Wisc. Milwaukee, etc.  How the hell can they turn it on in a win or go home tournament?  I don't get it.  Would they have this success in a 7 game playoff series?  OR do they just sleepwalk through their crappy conference?

WTF

Butler did not get blown out all season. Their losses were all very close. They ended the year playing their best ball plus they all have tourney experience.

They would not win a 7 game series with the top programs in the country.
 
Shelvin Mack is highly underrated (maybe the best clutch player in the tourney) and I still cannot understand why Tubby Smith or Billy Gillespie did not even offer him considering he is from Lexington, KY.

Brad Stevens is a robot basketball genius who looks like he just had to start shaving this year.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: bubu54 on March 27, 2011, 09:58:30 AM
Come one guys...you talk to much and its right in front of you...they play hard yes...there is a little luck yes...but most of all the play smart...when we aren't good thats what we miss...dumb mistakes...
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: CNS on March 27, 2011, 10:04:56 AM
He was fouled quit letting your inner tard get the best of you.

not butt hurt about this at all.  just an opinion from watching a game I really didnt give a crap about.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: Cartierfor3 on March 27, 2011, 10:08:29 AM
He was fouled quit letting your inner tard get the best of you.

not butt hurt about this at all.  just an opinion from watching a game I really didnt give a cac about.

Pitt's player was tarded for fouling.  Blame him.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: Panjandrum on March 27, 2011, 10:20:03 AM
extremely physical defense, outstanding screening, good shooters, ridiculously lucky.

Generally speaking, they don't turn the ball over much either.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: sys on March 27, 2011, 10:36:20 AM
Generally speaking, they don't turn the ball over much either.

pretty good commonality among good teams.  in some ways, it's amazing how well kstate did this year considering how poor they were at limiting turnovers.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: Panjandrum on March 27, 2011, 10:41:30 AM
Generally speaking, they don't turn the ball over much either.

pretty good commonality among good teams.  in some ways, it's amazing how well kstate did this year considering how poor they were at limiting turnovers.

I write it off to it being the best 3Pt shooting season KSU has had under Frank Martin.  It pushed up the eFG% and overcame some of that messy play.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: CNS on March 27, 2011, 10:48:30 AM
He was fouled quit letting your inner tard get the best of you.

not butt hurt about this at all.  just an opinion from watching a game I really didnt give a cac about.

Pitt's player was tarded for fouling.  Blame him.
def was a dumb move on his part, and if I was a Pitt fan he would be getting a lot of blame from me.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: catzacker on March 27, 2011, 11:31:51 AM
they play good/great defense, have a nba player (mack), a good college player (howard) and are experienced (they have a 2.98 exp rating, ku has a 2.99 - which is highest in the big 12 behind Tech).  they've also been fairly fortunate in nearly ever ncaa game.  it's that f'ing simple. 
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: kso_FAN on March 27, 2011, 12:31:41 PM
The hard thing is there really is no "one way" they win. Stevens maximizes the talent he has and his players make plays down the stretch at really an amazing rate. Against Pitt they played pretty terrible defense, but found a way to win. Against Wisconsin they played ridiculous defense which allowed them to build a huge lead and find a way to win. Against Florida they got down 9 with less than 8 minutes left and made enough plays to win.  Their experience definitely helps.

I am anxious to see what type of career Stevens has. There is no doubt he is a very good coach, but the standard he has set is pretty ridiculous, whether he stays at Butler or goes to a bigger school, especially considering how young he is.

And finally, a player committing a foul (even a dumb one) is still players deciding a game. It wasn't like either one of the fouls mentioned in the Pitt-Butler game were big time judgement calls.  You clearly see a foul like either of those you have to call it, but its still the players deciding the game. JMHO.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: the KHAN! on March 27, 2011, 12:57:04 PM
My theory is that their seemingly 12 year old coach is actually a guy with a Benjamin Button syndrome. He's been coaching basketball for about 100 years and is a genius. Don't let that boyish charm fool you.
Title: Re: Butler: How the hell do they do it?
Post by: Skipper44 on March 27, 2011, 02:57:15 PM
Thier is some question of boy wonder's recruiting, Licklighter(sp) recruited the core