JF was better than Klein. The Alabama defense would have absolutely clown suited Klein and our offense the way it was playing at the end of the year.. (That said, I think our defense proved against Oregon, as they did against a good Arkansas offense the year before that could have stood up well to Alabama).
What makes the JF situation quite humorous to me is knowing that CultAggie is probably the worst place for any underclassman to win something like the Heisman. Let's be honest, in the realm of major sports (Football and Men's Basketball) CultAggie is a monstrous underachiever. Remember, we're talking about a school that's literally bolting fake championships on to concrete walls at their football stadium. So while any Heisman winner is going to garner significant attention, at CultAggie they're going to be like teenage girls at a One Direction concert.