This has the feeling of one of those movies where the guy accidentally kills someone (hooker, drifter, etc) and gets his buddies to help him clean it up rather than do the right thing and call the cops -- then the rationalization begins:
"If I can just get rid of the body quick enough, no one will ever know, and no one has to go to jail"
"We can never speak of the unpleasantness again"
That said, I wouldn't complain if the current staff is retained