RG3 has played 4 games. 4. Way too early to make a decision on him (or cam, really).
Yeah, those guys are probably gonna tank. We should stick with Cassel or Quinn in 2013 rather than taking a risk.
I'm not saying don't get a quarterback but I'm way more comfortable with Barkley or another pro style guy than a guy who just throws the deep ball against non existent defenses.
Have you watched both Barkley and Smith play this season? Geno in every game he plays is making every single pass, not just the deep ball. Re-watch the Baylor game, many of the big plays where because he hit a receiver in stride and allowed them to turn upfield and make a play. Barkley has already thrown 5 picks and taken 7 sacks. Obviously he's faced better defenses (though Hawaii, Syracuse, and Cal aren't exactly great) but in the games I've seen of his he seems somewhat erratic on his throws. I'd take him in a heartbeat over Cassell, but he just screams bust to me. Geno will have some down games once he hits the meat of the BigXII schedule, but so did RG3.